Skip to main content

Head-On Crash in Montauk Injures Three

Thu, 09/30/2021 - 08:44

Three people were injured in a head-on collision in Montauk Friday morning in the most serious of a handful of traffic accidents last week.

Gavin Shirley of Montauk, 28, and Michele Stanchina of Fresh Meadows, 36, were stopped across from each other at the corner of South Essex Street and Montauk Highway before moving on. Ms. Stanchina, who was turning left onto the highway in a 2007 Volvo, told police she did not see Mr. Shirley's 2017 Hyundai, and the cars collided. Mr. Shirley and one of his passengers, a 3-year-old boy, were taken by ambulance to Stony Brook Southampton Hospital for an arm injury and facial bruising, respectively. Ms. Stanchina said she'd hurt her arm, but did not go to the hospital. Marshall and Sons towed both cars.

Later that day, Patricia Richardi of East Hampton "started uncontrollably sneezing," she told police, which led to her losing control of her car and striking a utility pole on Three Mile Harbor Road near Abraham's Path in East Hampton. Her arm was bruised, she said, but she declined a trip to the hospital. Bonac Buy and Sell towed away her 2018 Subaru.

E.H. Plazagordillo of East Hampton, 41, complained of neck pain after his 2004 Ford sedan was rear-ended last Thursday afternoon in slow-moving traffic on eastbound Montauk Highway in Wainscott. Driving a 2014 Honda sedan, Elizabeth Defronzo, 33, also of East Hampton, told police she did not realize that the car in front of hers had slowed down. Mr. Plazagordillo was evaluated on scene by an E.M.T., and declined further medical attention. Rob's Towing hauled away his car.

Two accidents in Sag Harbor last week involved buses. On Friday morning, while pulling into the stop in front of the village municipal building, a Suffolk County Transit bus struck a 2018 Chevrolet pickup truck legally parked nearby. The truck, owned by a 64-year-old Patchogue man, sustained rear bumper damage. The next morning, farther south on Main Street, a coach bus struck a 2021 Volvo parked in front of a residence near Howard Street. No further details were available on the latter accident, but no one was injured in either one. C.S.
 

Emergency Dispatch Cost Analysis Debated

With two months to go until the East Hampton Town Police Department takes over the lion’s share of emergency dispatching responsibilities from East Hampton Village, questions linger about the cost of the transition and how the town department will handle the new workload. 

Oct 30, 2025

East Hampton Had Role in High-Stakes Poker Scandal

Rigged, illegal, and high-stakes poker games have been held in recent years in various locales, including East Hampton, according to a federal indictment filed on Oct. 9. 

Oct 30, 2025

On the Police Logs 10.30.25

The shaving cream vandal struck again over the weekend, this time spraying the stuff around the interior and exterior of the men’s restroom in the Reutershan parking lot downtown Saturday night.

Oct 30, 2025

On the Police Logs 10.23.25

A dog had been barking on and off in a fenced-in backyard for four days, a Springs-Fireplace Road neighbor reported on the night of Oct.15, adding that the house appeared to be empty and abandoned. Police went to the property and found a large black-and-white husky, “whimpering and shivering.”

Oct 23, 2025

 

Your support for The East Hampton Star helps us deliver the news, arts, and community information you need. Whether you are an online subscriber, get the paper in the mail, delivered to your door in Manhattan, or are just passing through, every reader counts. We value you for being part of The Star family.

Your subscription to The Star does more than get you great arts, news, sports, and outdoors stories. It makes everything we do possible.