Skip to main content

History Below the Hoops at East Hampton's Herrick Park

Thu, 06/22/2023 - 10:29
Peter Zegler showed off some items found in dirt that until recently was covered by the basketball court in Herrick Park.
Durell Godfrey

Back in March, Peter Zegler and Bob Beck, metal detectorists, saw an opportunity to uncover some East Hampton Village history after learning of plans to renovate the fields at Herrick Park, and they requested permission from the village board to get to work.

On Friday, Mr. Zegler presented their findings to the board.

“We had a great time,” he said.

The two did some prep work before construction began, he said, to find out the “personality” of the park. They were disappointed to discover that during a 1980 renovation, a lot of topsoil was brought in, and the park regraded. This meant many of the treasures they hoped to find were perhaps a “good foot” below the surface.

For the first three hours, they found mostly modern items, said Mr. Zegler. “We found clad coins, and flip-tops from cans.”

They decided to wait until the tennis and basketball courts were removed, hoping they would find untouched 18th-century soil below.

The tennis courts turned out to be a nine-inch pile of asphalt set atop 18 inches of poured sand. Too deep.

The basketball court was far more fruitful. It had been laid over an expanse of undisturbed soil, and soon their metal detectors were beeping with excitement.

In 1740, Mr. Zegler reminded the trustees, the Gardiner Brown House, now home to the Ladies Village Improvement Society, was built, steps from where the basketball court had been. Most of their finds in the soil below were from that era. The team found flat buttons dating from the late 1600s to the late 1700s, which, Mr. Zegler said, were “the common button worn in farm fields after East Hampton was discovered.”

The men also found 18th-century “rose-head nails,” made by “nailers” who could turn out 2,000 a day, and a single musket ball, dating between 1720 and 1750, “used to shoot wild game,” that had likely slipped out of a someone’s pocket. A 1732 British halfpenny rounded out their metal findings, though they also unearthed a portion of a clay pipe, engraved with what may be tobacco leaves.

“People smoked tobacco and maybe some other stuff” with them, Mr. Zegler said. “You could find your favorite clay pipe at a tavern, on the wall.” Millions were made.

“It’s exciting when you find things like this,” he said. “On the un-landscaped property along Main Street, you’re bound to find a lot more of these items.”

Mayor Jerry Larsen encouraged him to make a shadow box of the finds, which would be put on display at Village Hall.  

Villages

‘Country’ Lawyer, Author, Painter, Man of the World

The pace at which Lenny Ackerman moves belies his 86 years. The prominent East End attorney writes a weekly column for The Mountain Messenger, has taken up painting, and has just published his fourth book.

Jul 31, 2025

Item of the Week: The A.O. Jones Hardware Store

This photograph from the C. Frank Dayton Photo Collection at the East Hampton Library shows the A.O. Jones Hardware Store at 51 Newtown Lane. Owned by Asa O. Jones (1857-1953), it later became East End Hardware and today is A.L.C., a clothing store.

Jul 31, 2025

Amagansett Summer Party for Joan Tulp

The Amagansett Village Improvement Society will tip its collective hat to Joan Tulp on Saturday. “I don’t think I’ve met anyone more committed to their hometown than Joan,” said Victor Gelb, who serves as co-president of the group with her.

Jul 31, 2025

 

Your support for The East Hampton Star helps us deliver the news, arts, and community information you need. Whether you are an online subscriber, get the paper in the mail, delivered to your door in Manhattan, or are just passing through, every reader counts. We value you for being part of The Star family.

Your subscription to The Star does more than get you great arts, news, sports, and outdoors stories. It makes everything we do possible.