Skip to main content

Water Tests at Navy Road in Montauk Scrutinized

Thu, 08/12/2021 - 11:58
Fort Pond Bay at Navy Road
Jane Bimson

Waterborne bacteria counts have surged at ponds, beaches, and bays this summer. 

One particular site that has had unusually high levels of bacteria is Fort Pond Bay in Montauk. According to Kate Rossi-Snook, an environmental advocate with the Concerned Citizens of Montauk, which administers the weekly water tests, they have “literally never had an elevated bacteria level” at the sampling site off Navy Road.

Enterococcus levels at Fort Pond Bay on Navy Road in Montauk have bounced between high and low this summer. Bacteria counts above 104 are considered a public health risk. 

The first sample with a high bacteria level this year at Navy Road was tested on June 29 and was off the charts. The bacteria, called enterococcus, which is associated with human waste, appeared for the next two weeks at "high" levels. From that point on, the bacteria count has switched each week from high to low. In the most recent data, from Aug. 10, there was an entero level of 63, in correlation with the pattern, a medium bacteria rate, significantly lower than the previous week's 168, rated "high." 

Early on, Ms Rossi-Snook suspected that an extraordinarily high level on June 29 was with the sampling process, and did not reflect actual water quality at the Navy Road site. She said that every now and then, a high sampling is “a drop in a bucket.” In reference to the source and solution, she “really can’t say, one way or another until we see a consistent trend.” She also brought up a situation from 2019, at Ditch Plain, in which there were elevated levels of bacteria as well, which she attributed to the dead whales washing up on shore. 

At other sites, water testing data from samples taken on Aug. 2 show that bacteria levels have risen. The high-risk areas in the latest results were Lake Montauk's East Creek and Benson Drive culvert, Tuthill Pond, Fort Pond Bay, and, at Accabonac Harbor, behind the Springs General Store. 

The medium-risk areas in Montauk included Little Reed Creek, West Lake, South Lake Beach, and Fort Pond at Industrial Road and the state launching ramp. 

Villages

The State of the Bays Is Mostly Bad

Sensational mentions of a flesh-eating bacterium aside, the State of the Bays symposium at the Stony Brook Southampton campus offered dire news regarding degraded waterways and climate change. 

Apr 30, 2026

Call ‘Flesh Eating’ Alarmist

The Vibrio vulnificus “flesh eating” bacterium “is not unusual in warm saltwater or brackish environments and does not necessarily indicate pollution or a widespread public health emergency,” the Southampton Town Trustees said in an advisory issued following a social media post that went viral.

Apr 30, 2026

Item of the Week: All Aboard the Fishermen’s Special

The L.I.R.R.’s Fishermen’s Special to Montauk and Hampton Bays was once a convenient and popular rail service for urban anglers. The photo here is from 1946.

Apr 30, 2026

 

Your support for The East Hampton Star helps us deliver the news, arts, and community information you need. Whether you are an online subscriber, get the paper in the mail, delivered to your door in Manhattan, or are just passing through, every reader counts. We value you for being part of The Star family.

Your subscription to The Star does more than get you great arts, news, sports, and outdoors stories. It makes everything we do possible.