Skip to main content

Attempted Swatting in Sag Harbor

Thu, 04/17/2025 - 10:23
The first swatting call to Sag Pizza, warning of a man with a possible bomb on his chest, came on Feb. 25.
Durell Godfrey

Sag Harbor Village police have received several reports of “swatting” calls from Main Street businesses recently, three from Sag Pizza and another, last week, to Apple Bank.

Swatting, according to 911.gov, is defined as falsely reporting an emergency to public safety, with the intent of getting a SWAT team response to a location where no emergency exists.”

On the phone Tuesday, Charlie Pirolo, director of operations for Sag Pizza, described the situation as “pretty unfortunate.”

“These are some serious threats they’re calling in,” he said.

The first call to Sag Pizza, warning of a man with a possible bomb on his chest, came on Feb. 25 and was immediately reported to police. The dispatcher alerted officers that it could be a false alarm, and they found no such person at the site. Whoever called Sag Pizza could not be reached.

On the afternoon of March 23, a caller alerted police that someone with a gun was at the Sag Pizza building. Officers found nothing suspicious, nor did a surveillance camera show anything out of the ordinary.

Then on April 2, a caller told the restaurant there was “a man with a gun, demanding $10,000,” holding a female hostage in the bathroom of the building. Police found both bathrooms empty and staff reported seeing and hearing nothing alarming. Mr. Pirolo said business was continuing as usual.

Most recently, on Saturday afternoon, a woman called Sag Harbor police directly and claimed there were several bombs in the vicinity of Apple Bank. They had an hour to defuse the bombs, she said, adding that notes “written in invisible ink” had been left at multiple locations around the village, with instructions on how to contact the caller.

Police again used the Hamptons.com live camera to survey the area, and saw no suspicious activity. Outside the bank, officers determined that the doors were closed and locked; nothing unusual was visible through the windows.

The same woman later called the East Hampton Village Police Department, whose dispatcher reported that she sounded like a “teenaged female,” who’d laughed repeatedly and said, “Okay, love you, Pookie Bear.”

The phone number she’d called from was international, and the report was deemed to be a swatting attempt.

All these reports remain under active investigation by the Sag Harbor Police Department, which had no further comment at this time.

They Know When You've Been Bad or Good

East Hampton Village is now home to 14 Flock license plate reader surveillance cameras, which amounts to one for every 108 full-time residents, if you go by the 2020 census data. They're heralded by local police for aiding in enforcement and investigations, but they use a technology that has proven controversial nationally with those concerned about civil liberties.

Dec 25, 2025

On the Logs 12.25.25

Responding Sunday night to a noise complaint from Wainscott Hollow Road, an officer heard loud music from a house and knocked on the door. The woman who answered said they were having a Christmas party.

Dec 25, 2025

Defied a Restraining Order

An East Hampton man was charged with a felony last week, accused of violating an active order of protection.

Dec 24, 2025

Town Police Dept. Ready for New Duties

The East Hampton Town Police Department says it is ready to take on dispatch responsibilities starting in January when it assumes responsibilities from East Hampton Village and becomes the primary Public Safety Answering Point, or P.S.A.P., in the town.

Dec 18, 2025

 

Your support for The East Hampton Star helps us deliver the news, arts, and community information you need. Whether you are an online subscriber, get the paper in the mail, delivered to your door in Manhattan, or are just passing through, every reader counts. We value you for being part of The Star family.

Your subscription to The Star does more than get you great arts, news, sports, and outdoors stories. It makes everything we do possible.