Skip to main content

Lawyers Debate Sag Harbor Goop Fire

Thu, 12/15/2022 - 08:42
Christine Sampson

Whatever happened to that late-June incident at the Goop shop in Sag Harbor, where two waiters were badly burned after a store employee toasted marshmallows for an event, using isopropyl alcohol?

It’s not in litigation, at least not yet. Lawyers for both sides are trying to negotiate a settlement.

Justin Blitz, the New York City-based lawyer for the two men, Mark Nilon and Nathaniel Meeks, says that while his clients have since gone back to work, each was badly burned in the June 25 incident.

That evening, the Goop retail store, founded by the actress Gwyneth Paltrow and headquartered in Santa Monica, Calif., hosted an event at its Bay Street shop, catered by Little Gem, which is owned by Mr. Blitz’s wife. (The catering company is not involved in the settlement discussions, the lawyer said.)

Little Gem provided the food and the waiters. Unknown to the two men, said Mr. Blitz, Goop, on its own, had set up a s’mores buffet, with a burner in a covered area outside.

According to police and fire marshal reports, a shop employee used rubbing alcohol to “kindle” the fire, and the vapors caused an explosion. Sag Harbor Fire Marshal Bruce Schiavoni cited Goop on a certificate of occupancy charge, and for lighting a flame underneath a flammable ceiling — in this case, a woven bamboo ceiling that was burned in the explosion.

Mr. Meeks was helicoptered to Stony Brook Hospital for burns on his back and hands; Mr. Nilon was taken to Stony Brook Southampton Hospital with facial burns. Police reported that “subjects stated that rubbing alcohol was added to candles, which caused a large explosion/fire.”

In the months that followed, said Mr. Blitz, both men paid follow-up visits to a number of doctors.

The lawyer said he was hopeful that the shop and the waiters will arrive at an amicable resolution of the case. Failing that, “the ultimate next step would be proceeding with litigation.”

An email sent to Goop’s corporate office for comment on the case did not receive an immediate response.

On the Police Logs 10.09.25

An “older gentleman” was at the bar at Rosie’s in Amagansett with a younger woman who “did not appear to be his daughter,” another patron, who was “concerned about her well-being,” reported Friday night. But she was the man’s daughter.

Oct 9, 2025

Fake IDs and Felony Charges

A 31-year-old man faces felony charges for possessing forged documents following a traffic stop in Sag Harbor early Friday morning.

Oct 9, 2025

Sun’s Glare Was to Blame

A cyclist was transported to Stony Brook Southampton Hospital on Friday afternoon after colliding with a BMW sedan on Route 114 in East Hampton.

Oct 9, 2025

On the Police Logs 10.02.25

Four men were seen “rearranging” the metal benches in front of the Yummylicious ice cream and frozen yogurt shop in Sag Harbor last week. They told a police officer they’d moved the benches “because they wanted to hang out.”

Oct 2, 2025

 

Your support for The East Hampton Star helps us deliver the news, arts, and community information you need. Whether you are an online subscriber, get the paper in the mail, delivered to your door in Manhattan, or are just passing through, every reader counts. We value you for being part of The Star family.

Your subscription to The Star does more than get you great arts, news, sports, and outdoors stories. It makes everything we do possible.