Skip to main content

Secret’s Out on Cinema’s $5 Mystery Movies

Thu, 09/11/2025 - 12:00
Theatergoers don’t know what film they’re in for on Regal Cinema’s Mystery Movie Nights, but they do know it will cost just $5. In the lobby one Monday this summer were, from left, Marie Lombardi, Joanna Tschurtschenthaler, Julie Evans, and Chini Alarco.
Durell Godfrey

Imagine walking into the movies, buying popcorn, sitting down in the theater, and waiting for your movie to start, but there’s a catch — you don’t know what movie is playing. That’s the experience of Regal’s Monday Mystery Movies, on show at the East Hampton Cinema about two Mondays a month at 7 p.m. In addition to the fun of the surprise, there’s another draw: The movies only cost $5.

Regal’s Monday Mystery Movies are a nationwide offering, and at the East Hampton branch they attract a small group of dedicated regulars. One of them, Joanna Tschurtschenthaler, said she enjoys seeing the same faces at each Monday Mystery screening. She likes socializing in the lobby and then having a quiet night to herself inside the theater.

While there tends to be an older crowd at certain points during the year, “everyone loves it,” the theater’s management said. Mystery Movie Night patrons also get a chance to see a new movie before it’s released in theaters.

Dan Glass of Sag Harbor called Monday Mystery movies a “hidden gem [that] you can’t really find anywhere anymore.”

Mystery Movies have been running for almost three years here, with over 50 films shown, including hits such as the new “Jurassic Park” and “Gladiator II.” One of Mr. Glass’s favorites was “Paint,” a comedy about a television painter named Carl Nargle, whose character is loosely inspired by Bob Ross. Ms. Tschurtschenthaler enjoyed “The Fire Inside,” a sports drama about the journey of a female boxer from Flint, Mich.

You won’t find Mystery Movie Night on the theater’s marquee, but head to Regal’s website, regmovies.com, search “Monday Mystery Movie” and select the East Hampton theater to find the next scheduled date: in this case Monday, Sept. 22.

—

Quinn Corleto was a participant in The East Hampton Star’s Summer Academy.

Villages

B-52s Founder Gets Hollywood Boulevard Star

Fred Schneider, who lives here, on the legendary new wave band’s 50-year rise from the college town of Athens, Ga., to the Hollywood Walk of Fame. 

Nov 5, 2026

Soul of Sag Harbor in the Balance

Spurred by the arrival of more retail chains and disappointment at how they were changing the face of the village, Sag Harbor commissioned a study on what a “formula store” is and how to control them.

Nov 5, 2026

Scallop Season: Bad News on the Half Shell

East Hampton Town waters will open to bay scallop harvesting at sunrise on Sunday, though this year’s crop is understood to be yet another in a string of disappointments, with few of the local delicacy’s population surviving. 

Nov 5, 2026

 

Your support for The East Hampton Star helps us deliver the news, arts, and community information you need. Whether you are an online subscriber, get the paper in the mail, delivered to your door in Manhattan, or are just passing through, every reader counts. We value you for being part of The Star family.

Your subscription to The Star does more than get you great arts, news, sports, and outdoors stories. It makes everything we do possible.