Skip to main content

Arrested in Two Towns in Two Days

Thu, 03/05/2026 - 12:23

An East Hampton woman had run-ins with police in both East Hampton and Southampton Towns last week, both leading to felony charges.

Madeline Tavernier, 32, was arrested by East Hampton police on Feb. 25 after they say she destroyed another person’s iPhone 15 by “slamming” it onto a truck bed in the parking lot of 44 Three Mile Harbor Road — the current home of Frankie’s Fabulous Italiano.

Police said that because the damage to the phone was in excess of $600, they charged her with criminal mischief in the third degree, a felony that carries as many as four years in prison.

That was minor compared to the charges she would face in Southampton.

Although she was released on her own recognizance last Thursday by East Hampton Town Justice David Filer, Southampton police picked her up that same day on felony grand larceny charges.

According to Southampton police, Ms. Tavernier’s former employer alerted them in January that a company credit card and a personal credit card had been used for nearly $17,000 in online purchases over the summer. In a press release, Southampton police said Ms. Tavernier used the cards on various websites starting in July.

After a nearly two-month-long investigation, police charged Ms. Tavernier with grand larceny in the third degree. The charges carry a varied sentencing guideline which spans from probation to seven years in prison.

Ms. Tavernier was arraigned in Southampton Town Justice Court, where she was released on her own recognizance. She is due back in court on April 14.

Separately, East Hampton Village police arrested a Mastic man Friday night on a felony charge related to the removal of his vehicle’s identification number.     

According to reports, Jose Munoz, 47, was pulled over on Woods Lane when officers said they noticed one of his headlights was out. When they noticed the Toyota Tundra’s VIN plate was missing and the trailer he was hauling was not registered, they charged him with the felony. He was additionally charged with seven violations and released on an appearance ticket. He is due in court on March 18.              

White Powder, White Mucus

A man police said was waxing poetic about his rescue dog during a traffic stop is facing a felony drug charge and charges of resisting arrest after they reportedly found cocaine in his car on Friday night.

Sep 3, 2026

Driver Had No Interlock, Police Say

East Hampton Town police charged a Springs man with felony-level driving while intoxicated on Aug. 22 after he had turned into a Pantigo Road parking lot at 2:15 that morning.

Sep 3, 2026

Driver Said She Fell Asleep

Four people were hospitalized last week after two cars collided on Hand’s Creek Road in East Hampton. Police said a driver fell asleep at the wheel of her Toyota sedan on the afternoon of Aug. 17. The car swerved into the oncoming lane and crashed head-on into a Honda sedan.

Aug 27, 2026

Alleged Dealers at Large

According to a report released this week, two men arrested in Amagansett in mid-June and charged with felony possession of a controlled substance with intent to sell, are still at large, awaiting future court appearances.

Aug 27, 2026

 

Your support for The East Hampton Star helps us deliver the news, arts, and community information you need. Whether you are an online subscriber, get the paper in the mail, delivered to your door in Manhattan, or are just passing through, every reader counts. We value you for being part of The Star family.

Your subscription to The Star does more than get you great arts, news, sports, and outdoors stories. It makes everything we do possible.