Skip to main content

String of Car Thefts in East Hampton Is Under Investigation

Sun, 09/13/2020 - 11:27
East Hampton Village Police are investigating the theft of two luxury vehicles from a driveway on Dunemere Lane.
Doug Kuntz

Update, Sept. 16, 4 p.m.: One of five high-end vehicles reported stolen earlier this week in East Hampton Town and Village has been recovered, according to the East Hampton Town Police Department.

A 2017 Land Rover that went missing Friday night from a house on Montauk Avenue in Northwest was found in the Newark, N.J., area on Saturday morning. Det. Sgt. Daniel Toia of the East Hampton Town Police said yesterday that there was no damage to the vehicle and it has been returned to its owner.

The Land Rover was one of three vehicles stolen from residences in the neighborhood of Springy Banks Road, East Hampton, overnight on Friday. Thieves also took a 2010 Land Rover and a 2019 BMW X5. "All vehicles were reported to have been left unlocked with the keys in the vehicle," town police said in a statement.

Update, Sept. 14, 2:55 p.m.: Five high-end vehicles were stolen between Friday night and Saturday morning in East Hampton Town and Village, police said.

On Monday morning, East Hampton Village Police confirmed that two Land Rovers, one a 2015 model with New York plates and the other a 2016 model with Connecticut plates, had been reported missing from a Dunemere Lane residence on Saturday morning.  

No additional information on the incident was immediately available.

East Hampton Town Police on Sunday said they were investigating the theft of three other vehicles — a 2017 Land Rover, a 2010 Land Rover, and a 2019 BMW X5 — from driveways of residences in the vicinity of Springy Banks Road in East Hampton.

Originally, Sept. 13: On Sunday, the East Hampton Town Police detectives division announced an investigation into a string of high-end vehicle thefts that they said took place during the early-morning hours on Saturday.

A 2017 Land Rover, a 2010 Land Rover, and a 2019 BMW X5 were stolen from driveways of residences in the vicinity of Springy Banks Road in East Hampton. “All vehicles were reported to have been left unlocked with the keys in the vehicle,” police said.

Anyone with information has been asked to call the Police Department at 631-537-7575. Calls will be kept confidential.

The Southampton Town Police Department is also investigating a series of thefts of luxury cars and sport utility vehicles, with 12 such thefts ranging from Sagaponack to Tuckahoe since January, according to a press release from Southampton Town.

East Hampton Town police indicated on Facebook on Saturday that “this crime spree has reached East Hampton Town.”

“Please lock your vehicles,” police said.

With reporting by Doug Kuntz and Bella Lewis

On the Police Logs 12.18.25

A security guard at Pierson High School in Sag Harbor reported a “suspicious male” wearing a face mask and “riding a bicycle in circles” near the school gym. The young man subsequently told police he was waiting for his friends to get out of school, and said he was wearing a mask “because it’s cold outside today.”

Dec 18, 2025

Father and Son Injured in Crosswalk

Two automobile accidents on Montauk Highway, one in Wainscott and another in Amagansett, resulted in injuries last week, as did a third in Springs.

Dec 18, 2025

On the Police Logs 12.11.25

A caller reported a “suspicious package” near the westbound Jitney Stop on Main Street in the village Saturday, describing it as a suitcase next to a garbage can. When police arrived, an 89-year-old woman standing next to the suitcase informed them that it was hers.

Dec 11, 2025

E-Biker Injured in Collision

A 70-year-old man from the Bronx was seriously injured in an e-bike accident in Montauk late Tuesday afternoon.

Dec 11, 2025

 

Your support for The East Hampton Star helps us deliver the news, arts, and community information you need. Whether you are an online subscriber, get the paper in the mail, delivered to your door in Manhattan, or are just passing through, every reader counts. We value you for being part of The Star family.

Your subscription to The Star does more than get you great arts, news, sports, and outdoors stories. It makes everything we do possible.