Skip to main content

Felony Drunken Driving for Sag Harbor Woman

Thu, 05/23/2019 - 06:39

East Hampton Town police charged a Sag Harbor woman with felony drunken driving Sunday night after finding her 2014 Ford on the shoulder of Montauk Highway in Amagansett, engine running.

Melissa Diana Scarlato, who was behind the wheel, was asked if she had been drinking and reportedly replied that she had had "two martinis at the Tavern."

Failing roadside sobriety tests, she was placed under arrest and taken to headquarters, where police said a breath test produced a reading of .16, twice the .08 number that defines intoxication. Because she was convicted of misdemeanor drunken driving in 2008, the current charge is a felony. She was released from police custody to deal with an undisclosed medical condition, and will be arraigned in East Hampton Town Justice Court today.

Town police also arrested Brian M. Fisher, 22, of Springs, after stopping his 2014 Ford Focus on Montauk Highway in Montauk for insufficient brake lights, the second such summons since last month. This time, however, he ended up in handcuffs on a misdemeanor charge of driving while intoxicated. At headquarters, his breath test reportedly returned a reading slightly over the .08 mark.

Sag Harbor Village police made two alcohol-related arrests this past week. Victoria D. De Lesseps of Brooklyn, 22, driving a 2003 Land Rover, was pulled over on Main Street a little after midnight Friday; police said she was driving without headlights. At headquarters, her breath test registered an alleged .15. She was released the next morning without bail.

William C. Mead of East Moriches, 24, was driving a 2008 Mercedes Benz on Bay Street when the car almost struck a curb, then swerved across the road into the oncoming lane of traffic, according to the report. His breath test produced a .17 reading. He, too, was released without bail.

Yancy Victoria Butler, the actress whose .31 reading sent her to the hospital after her arrest in Sag Harbor on April 3, was arraigned in the village's Justice Court Friday on a misdemeanor charge of aggravated drunken driving. First, though, she reported to police headquarters on Division Street to have her fingerprints and mug shot taken. Because of her condition at the time of her arrest, police were not able to complete processing her. She was released without bail, and is now in an in-patient rehabilitation institution.  

Alleged Dealers at Large

According to a report released this week, two men arrested in Amagansett in mid-June and charged with felony possession of a controlled substance with intent to sell, are still at large, awaiting future court appearances.

Aug 27, 2026

On the Police Logs 08.27.26

Late Saturday night, police found a man on Bay Street described as “highly intoxicated” who said he was “attempting to adjust the driver’s seat” of a parked BMW that police said did not belong to him. While he does own a BMW, they said, that one was not his.

Aug 27, 2026

Sag Harbor Teen Found Safe

Update: Sag Harbor Village police said Saturday that a 16-year-old girl reported missing on Thursday had been located and is safe.

Aug 21, 2026

On the Police Logs 08.20.26

No crime was committed on Aug. 12 on Front Street in Springs, where police responded to a report that a man was holding a shotgun. Police said it was in fact a BB gun, which the man told them he uses to scare off squirrels and other small animals.

Aug 20, 2026

 

Your support for The East Hampton Star helps us deliver the news, arts, and community information you need. Whether you are an online subscriber, get the paper in the mail, delivered to your door in Manhattan, or are just passing through, every reader counts. We value you for being part of The Star family.

Your subscription to The Star does more than get you great arts, news, sports, and outdoors stories. It makes everything we do possible.