Skip to main content

Falafel Takeout Opens in Sag Harbor

Mon, 05/15/2023 - 13:52
What the Falafel has opened on Division Street in Sag Harbor, offering sandwiches, bowls, wraps, and more, all featuring the Middle Eastern street food.
Christopher Gangemi

"You can never say where falafel is from," said Alidz Alexandrian, owner of the recently opened, What the Falafel street food spot at 51 Division Street in Sag Harbor. "The Turkish are going to say it's theirs. The Lebanese will say it's theirs. There are so many styles of falafel."

One thing can be said about falafel in Sag Harbor, however. It is a welcome new vegetarian and vegan takeout option. 

Ms. Alexandrian, an Armenian who was born and raised in Lebanon, prepares hers in the Lebanese style, which she says, comes down to a more balanced mixture of chickpeas to cilantro and parsley and the blend of spices used.

Falafel is one of the world's oldest street foods, but What the Falafel is the first South Fork establishment to make it its specialty. Ms. Alexandrian comes from a restaurant family. "We lived in the city for 10 years, working in our family-owned Lebanese Armenian fine dining restaurant. The lease was going to end but we didn't plan to renew. My husband was managing and when searching for a new job, was hired by Baron's Cove as general manager, so we moved out here in 2019." The Alexandrians have an 8-year-old daughter who attends Sag Harbor Elementary School.

They're not just jumping into the concept. They tried it out first with a "ghost kitchen" based in Ithaca, N.Y. A ghost kitchen is not attached to a physical space, instead, it's for takeout only. Also known as a "cloud kitchen," it shares another restaurant's kitchen. "It worked out very well," said Ms. Alexandrian. "We've been up in Cayuga for a year now."

"We bake the pita in house every day. Everything is done on the spot, fresh daily. Our falafels are made from scratch, nothing comes pre-made from the outside."

Falafel is often fried, but for the health conscious, Ms. Alexandrian offers a baked falafel wrap. Avoiding gluten or carbs? A falafel bowl could be the answer.

Aside from the expected falafel sandwiches, the menu includes hummus options, falafel salad bowls, and even a popular vegan tahini shake.

Made of sesame, almond milk, and sugar, it's a surprising dessert. "You would never think it would taste how it does. Every person can't believe how good it is," said Ms. Alexandrian.

If you're trying to wean your children from chicken nuggets, you could find a worse way than with Ms. Alexandrian's falafel dippers, which come in boxes of six or 12 with pita bread and dipping sauces.

The Alexandrians' minimalistic website, at wtfalafel.co allows for ordering through the toast app. Scheduled orders are a convenient option and they're partnering with DoorDash and Uber Eats. You'll pay $15 for most falafel sandwiches and $15 to $18 for one of the green bowls. 

Ms. Alexandrian said chalkboard specials will soon supplement their online menu and will only be available to walk-in customers. They will be open year-round. Current hours are Tuesday through Sunday from 11:30 a.m. to 8 p.m.
 

News for Foodies 08.28.25

Pete Wells, former New York Times restaurant critic, comes to Guild Hall, South Fork Bakery operates a new cafe at the Rogers Memorial Library, and Feniks opens in Southampton.

Aug 28, 2025

Star Academy Students Toast Smokey Buns

Smokey Buns, a conveniently located burger joint, and Scoop and Waffle, a sweet little ice cream spot, off Park Place in East Hampton, were the perfect spots for the students of The Star’s Summer Academy to have a casual meal together on a Friday afternoon and try their hands at restaurant reviewing.

Aug 21, 2025

Local Peanut Butter Is Here

Walter Kim, a Sag Harbor resident, decided that if he wanted additive-free peanut butter, he would have to make and market his own. Enter Sagg Peanut Butter.

Aug 21, 2025

News for Foodies 08.14.25

Seafood paella is dished up every Wednesday evening at the fish farm on Napeague for as long as the weather permits.

Aug 14, 2025

 

Your support for The East Hampton Star helps us deliver the news, arts, and community information you need. Whether you are an online subscriber, get the paper in the mail, delivered to your door in Manhattan, or are just passing through, every reader counts. We value you for being part of The Star family.

Your subscription to The Star does more than get you great arts, news, sports, and outdoors stories. It makes everything we do possible.