Skip to main content

Man's Recipe: Pennsylvania Dutch Pfeffernusse, 1957

Thu, 12/12/1957 - 10:23

The Pennsylvania Dutch (now known more commonly and accurately as Pennsylvania German) are famous for their good cooking, and the first dining club in America was organized in 1732 in Philadelphia.

I was interested to learn that in 1725, Dutch farmers began building the huge, lumbering Conestoga wagons — the same type that was used by pioneer families when they trekked across the western plains. The original use of the wagons was to haul the farmers’ crops of foods and grains to market.

The Pennsylvania Dutch were and still are noted for their culinary achievements and gracious hospitality. It became a tradition to put exactly seven sweets and seven sours on the table whenever guests ate with the family.

Today's cookie is from Mrs. George Steele Wheatley, Christiana, Pa. You need: one fourth pound butter, two cups sugar, three eggs beaten, one cup thick sour cream, two tablespoons soda, four to four and a half cups flour, one teaspoon cream of tartar, one teaspoon nutmeg freshly ground, one fourth teaspoon salt.

Cream the butter and sugar until fluffy. Add the beaten eggs and mix smooth.

Add the sour cream in which the soda has been dissolved. Then stir in the flour which has been sifted with cream of tartar, nutmeg, and salt. Flour should be added to make a fairly stiff batter, so it can be dropped by teaspoonfuls.

Place on greased baking sheets in mounds the size of a large walnut. Bake at 375-400 degrees, 10 or 12 minutes, and remove from pan while warm. Mrs. Wheatley says, "I have better results if dough is chilled."

Tags Recipes

News for Foodies: Tuna and Omakase

Sen restaurant will host a tuna breakdown demonstration and a 13-course omakase dinner.

Jan 8, 2026

Say Cheese (or Caviar), Day or Night

Self Provisions, a storefront attached to Cavaniola’s Gourmet Cheese in Sag Harbor, is “always open,” as is proclaimed by an illuminated sign on the wall at the entrance. Two large, brightly lit vending machines dominate the space, with offerings ranging from sea salt crackers and slabs of French butter to jars of caviar and curated gift boxes — and, of course, cheese.

Dec 25, 2025

New Year’s Eve at Almond

Almond restaurant in Bridgehampton will celebrate New Year’s Eve with a locally sourced five-course prix fixe dinner that will include party favors and a champagne toast.

Dec 25, 2025

News for Foodies 12.25.25

Lulu Kitchen and Bar in Sag Harbor is offering New Year’s Eve dinner packages to go, and the Ram’s Head Inn on Shelter Island will serve a New Year’s Eve prix fixe and can host private parties any night of the week.

Dec 25, 2025

 

Your support for The East Hampton Star helps us deliver the news, arts, and community information you need. Whether you are an online subscriber, get the paper in the mail, delivered to your door in Manhattan, or are just passing through, every reader counts. We value you for being part of The Star family.

Your subscription to The Star does more than get you great arts, news, sports, and outdoors stories. It makes everything we do possible.