Skip to main content

On the Police Logs 08.07.25

Thu, 08/07/2025 - 10:27

Amagansett

A Scrimshaw Lane man called police at around 1 a.m. on Friday after spotting a pair of shoes, not his, on his lawn. Officers responded, only to discover an intoxicated stranger asleep in a chair in the backyard, who stated upon waking that he was visiting from Connecticut and thought he was at his residence. Police drove him to a house a few minutes away, and watched as he “entered without incident.” The homeowner declined to press charges.

East Hampton Village

After a “disoriented” raccoon was reported wandering around a Lily Pond Lane house last Thursday morning, police contacted wildlife rescue, which said someone would respond to capture it. A neighbor called back that afternoon, however, to report a  “lethargic” raccoon “foaming at the mouth.” The neighbor had called wildlife rescue as well, which said that the animal “sounds sick” and likely had distemper, a highly contagious and often fatal viral disease, but that no one was available to respond at that time. Village police removed the raccoon from the property.

A group of teenagers accused of throwing eggs at cars in the Stop and Shop parking lot on Friday evening told police they’d been “tossing eggs to each other” but had not hit any cars. They were advised not to throw eggs in a crowded parking lot.

Montauk

A Grant Drive man left his Big Cat e-bike, valued at $1,700, on the shoulder of Old Montauk Highway on the evening of July 27 with a flat tire. While walking to work the next morning, he told police, he found it gone. An initial search of the area was not successful.

Sag Harbor

Police went to Howard Street on the afternoon of July 30 after a caller described a “possible unauthorized speed bump” there, and found that a plastic speed bump had indeed been installed in the road. They removed it, found its owner, and explained that speed bumps cannot be placed on public roads without authorization. The owner complained of speeding vehicles in the area throughout the day, “especially in the morning between 7 and 10 a.m.,” and requested extra police patrols during those hours.

A group entered the Harbor Shop convenience store just before midnight on Friday, and on the way to the cashier dropped a case of beer. One of the cans burst, and they attempted to hide it, the cashier told police. She asked them to retrieve and pay for the damaged case, she said, and they complied at first but then “got upset” when she refused to sell them more alcohol, and stole a bottle of wine. She asked that the incident be documented.

On Saturday afternoon, a “regular customer” of a Main Street boutique dropped a pink floral hair clip valued at $15 into her bag while browsing and left without paying, the owner told police. She would request payment the next time the woman was in the store, she said, but would also like an order banning her from the property. She was advised to contact police when the woman returns. (In a similar incident last month, six of the same clips were stolen from the store by a group of girls, who have not been found.)

A patron of Sag Pizza, accused Sunday night of threatening to “stab the staff with a fork” after being asked to leave the premises, told police he’d paid for his food and was trying to sit down and eat with his family when an employee took the food and told him to leave. Surveillance footage reportedly showed the man getting up from the table, fork in hand, and approaching the employee “in a menacing manner,” according to police. The employee declined to press charges and the family left without further incident.

Wainscott

In the early hours of Sunday, on Daniel’s Hole Road, a Brooklyn man was charged with reckless endangerment. Police said he’d “run at full sprint” and kicked a plastic “prop wall,” estimated to weigh about 300 pounds, which then fell over onto another man, who reportedly experienced “substantial pain” as a result and briefly lost consciousness. The Brooklyn man was arraigned in town court later that day and released with a ticket to return at a later date.

On the Logs 01.22.26

Someone stole a plaster elephant statue from outside the front door of an apartment on Montauk Highway in Amagansett. The resident told police that she had an idea of who stole the statue, but the accused denied taking it.

Jan 22, 2026

911 Switch Is Delayed

When contract negotiations for 911 dispatching broke down between East Hampton Town and Village last spring, it became clear that the East Hampton Town Police Department would begin taking the bulk of 911 calls in the township from the village. The turnover was to occur on Jan. 1, but it has now been delayed for at least a month.

Jan 15, 2026

On the Logs 01.15.26

“Unwanted guests” were trying to take his belongings and refusing to leave, a Brandywine Drive, Sag Harbor, resident reported to 911 last Thursday, adding that one of them wouldn’t wake up and “may have overdosed.”

Jan 15, 2026

Teen Is Struck in Crosswalk

An 18-year-old was struck by a Honda sedan while crossing Newtown Lane in East Hampton on Saturday evening, near the intersection of Muchmore Lane.

Jan 15, 2026

 

Your support for The East Hampton Star helps us deliver the news, arts, and community information you need. Whether you are an online subscriber, get the paper in the mail, delivered to your door in Manhattan, or are just passing through, every reader counts. We value you for being part of The Star family.

Your subscription to The Star does more than get you great arts, news, sports, and outdoors stories. It makes everything we do possible.