Skip to main content

Deer Broke the Windshield

Thu, 08/21/2025 - 11:22

A Brooklyn man was injured early Saturday evening on Skimhampton Road in Amagansett after his Hertz rental car collided with a deer.

Jamil Mahmoud Nathoo, 46, told East Hampton Town police the animal had jumped out in front of the Ford S.U.V. near the intersection of Eileen’s Path. It hit the driver’s-side front fender, breaking the windshield, he said, and in the impact, his head hit the rearview mirror. He was transported by ambulance to the Stony Brook East Hampton Emergency Room for evaluation.

Last Thursday afternoon, also in Amagansett, two S.U.V.s, a Mazda and a Buick, were involved in a collision on Montauk Highway. According to the police report, the driver of the Buick, which was also a rental from Hertz, Muriel Manigk of Cleveland Heights, Ohio, 19, was stopped in westbound traffic near the intersection of Hand Lane when the Mazda, driven by Rosa Ayala of Wainscott, 60, rear-ended it. Ms. Manigk complained of neck pain but refused medical treatment; Ms. Ayala was not injured.

The afternoon before, a Toyota rear-ended a Chrysler near Kirk Park Beach in Montauk. Lei Zhang of Syosset, 47, the Chrysler driver, told police she’d been driving east on Main Street and had stopped at a crosswalk to allow a pedestrian to cross when the Toyota ran into the back of her car. She complained of whiplash, and her 13-year-old passenger reportedly sustained bruising to her back. Both were transported by Montauk E.M.S. to the Stony Brook East Hampton emergency room.

The Toyota was driven by Taylor Grace Jarvis Kerns of San Pedro, Calif., 22, who was not injured. Both cars sustained minor damage.

On the Police Logs 11.19.26

An Amagansett resident told police last week that she had just driven by a suitcase lying “in the middle of the street” near the entrance to the Reutershan parking lot.

Nov 19, 2026

Distracted by Her Phone

A Southampton woman suffered head injuries last week when she crashed her car in Montauk after reportedly looking at a weather notification on her phone.

Nov 19, 2026

On the Police Logs 11.12.26

A cygnet swan standing in the middle of Cove Hollow Road and blocking traffic on Nov. 2 proved to be uninjured and eventually flew to Georgica Pond.

Nov 12, 2026

Man Jailed in ‘Violent’ Rape

After responding to a domestic incident last week, town police charged an East Hampton man with rape and forcible compulsion.

Nov 12, 2026

 

Your support for The East Hampton Star helps us deliver the news, arts, and community information you need. Whether you are an online subscriber, get the paper in the mail, delivered to your door in Manhattan, or are just passing through, every reader counts. We value you for being part of The Star family.

Your subscription to The Star does more than get you great arts, news, sports, and outdoors stories. It makes everything we do possible.