Skip to main content

Shoplifter Hits Sag Harbor Store

Thu, 02/27/2025 - 10:52

Update, Friday, Feb. 28, 11 a.m.: The clothing shop LoveShackFancy on Madison Street in Sag Harbor reported two separate thefts over the weekend.

On Saturday evening, a woman was in the store with her child when an employee approached them to say that the child’s missing wallet had been found on the floor in a different part of the store. Forty dollars was found to be missing when the wallet was opened.

The employee then checked the store’s surveillance camera. The security footage first showed the wallet lying on a table near the front door of the store.

A woman was then seen picking it up, opening it, removing the money, and then setting it back down in the same place. That same woman then went to the employee to report the wallet’s location.

The footage then showed her leaving the store in the company of an older woman. Using an outdoor camera, Sag Harbor Village police spotted the pair walking north from the store before moving out of view. As of press time they have not been found.

On Sunday evening, a dress valued at $595 was stolen from LoveShackFancy. An employee told police that a woman had taken the dress off the rack, gone into the changing room, and “without closing the curtain” placed the dress into a blue bag.

She then walked about the store for a few more minutes, the employee said, before walking out without paying for the pink-and-white floral dress, labeled as a “Theodore Dress.” The store features a dress of a similar description online.

Police canvassed the area looking for the person without success. But on Thursday afternoon around 2, village police arrested a person in connection with the theft on Sunday at Grindstone Coffee and Donuts on Main Street. 

The person had yet to be arraigned or even put on the docket to be seen before a judge as of Friday morning. 

On the Police Logs 08.06.26

A group involved in a “singing ritual” were questioned by police on Havens Beach in Sag Harbor around midnight on July 28 after someone called in a noise complaint for “chanting.” The group left the beach immediately.

Aug 6, 2026

Former Sag Harbor PTA Treasurer Admits She Stole Money

A former co-treasurer of the Sag Harbor Elementary School PTA will be required to pay $14,487 in restitution after pleading guilty to stealing over $10,000 from the group, Suffolk County District Attorney Raymond A. Tierney announced this week.

Aug 6, 2026

Five Hurt in Old Stone Highway Crash

Five people were injured on the afternoon of July 28, with three taken to the hospital, after two cars collided on Old Stone Highway in Amagansett.

Aug 6, 2026

Accused Double RL Burglar a No-Show

A woman accused of stealing over $20,000 worth of merchandise from the Ralph Lauren Double RL clothing store in East Hampton Village was a no-show in court last week.

Aug 6, 2026

 

Your support for The East Hampton Star helps us deliver the news, arts, and community information you need. Whether you are an online subscriber, get the paper in the mail, delivered to your door in Manhattan, or are just passing through, every reader counts. We value you for being part of The Star family.

Your subscription to The Star does more than get you great arts, news, sports, and outdoors stories. It makes everything we do possible.