Skip to main content

On the Police Logs 11.09.23

Thu, 11/09/2023 - 09:54

Amagansett

Police questioned a man who was seen walking on the railroad tracks at the train station on the afternoon of Oct. 30. The man told police he was fine, but refused to give police his name, and boarded the westbound train a few minutes later.

At Albert’s Landing Beach, police are investigating an incident of trespassing in which someone dragged a trash bin around to the back of a building and stood on it to access a window. The out-of-place bin was discovered on Oct. 30 and reported by a town parks employee. Nothing was missing or damaged.

East Hampton

Two young men, one in a tan sweater and another in a blue shirt, were seen fighting in front of the East Hampton Farm Museum on Cedar Street on Halloween. They had been separated by the time police arrived.

An Oakview Highway resident was given a verbal warning by an officer on Friday afternoon for burning leaves and brush in a fire pit, which is not permitted in the town.

A woman who lives on Pine Street called police on Saturday around 8:30 p.m. after seeing flashlights shining into her bedroom window. Officers checked the property and found nothing amiss. They also said the lights she saw may have been from officers “checking the rear fields of the high school with flashlights during patrol” earlier that night.

Bruce Damark, proprietor of Damark’s Market on Three Mile Harbor Road, reported seeing a man steal a pack of Boar’s Head bacon on Friday morning. An officer questioned a man who had been seen walking from the deli to his residence. The man admitted to taking the bacon and returned to the store to pay $8. He’s not permitted there anymore.

Montauk

Last Thursday afternoon, police received a call about a missing ladder and signs that had been pulled out of the ground at Kenny’s Castaways. Officers reviewed security camera footage with the property owner, Edward Kenny, and are still investigating the matter.

In three separate predawn incidents between Halloween and Saturday, three people were seen fishing late at night from private docks at Rough Riders Landing off Fort Pond Road. All complied with officers’ instructions to leave immediately, and officers advised the management to provide better security there. A similar incident occurred Sunday at about 1:30 a.m. at Duryea’s Lobster Deck.

Sag Harbor

Meredith Ostrom reported that her engagement ring fell off her finger at Murf’s Backstreet Tavern on Oct. 27. Valued at around $40,000, it had not yet been found as of press time. Murf’s took to Instagram this week to spread the word that the ring is missing.

Another case of lost property, this one four days later, ended happily: Eiman Aziz of New York City lost his iPhone on Main Street on the morning of Nov. 1. He inquired with the police about six hours later at headquarters, where the phone was waiting for him.

A Mickey’s Carting driver reported seeing smoke coming from the engine of his truck on the afternoon of Oct. 31. He happened to be in front of the Sag Harbor Fire Department headquarters on Brick Kiln Road, leading to a quick response. No fire was detected and the driver went on his way. He soon called again about a similar problem, though by that time, reports show, he was in North Sea, within Southampton Town police jurisdiction.

Bob Bori, the village harbormaster, reported the theft of a cart from the public docks on West Water Street on Nov. 1. It was valued at about $300. Anyone who sees it will know it by its green color and “Village of Sag Harbor” label and is encouraged to contact police.

On Saturday night, police received a call from a Main Street residence concerning front-door locks that had been “cemented over and tampered with.” The investigation is ongoing into what was deemed third-degree criminal tampering, so no further information was available by press time.

Springs

Erik Schwab, a Springs School teacher, reported late Friday afternoon that the rear liftgate window on his 2020 Jeep had been broken in the nearly empty school parking lot. “There was no apparent evidence of what caused the window to break,” police said in the report.

 

Swerving Over the White Line

A 34-year-old man faces two felony drunken-driving charges following his arrest on the night of Aug. 3.

Aug 14, 2025

Rear-End Crashes in the Village

A Sag Harbor woman was injured on Aug. 6 after a westbound Mercedes sedan rear-ended her Jeep on Montauk Highway near Green Hollow Road.

Aug 14, 2025

Children Were in the Truck

A Rocky Point man was charged Sunday night with assault with a deadly weapon. East Hampton Village police said he had thrown a beer bottle at another man’s face as they were seated in a pickup truck a Montauk Highway intersection.

Aug 14, 2025

Montauk Boat Death Remains Unsolved Puzzle

More than a week after the body of Martha Nolan-O’Slatarra, a 33-year-old Manhattan-based Irish entrepreneur, was found on a boat docked at the Montauk Yacht Club, very little has been publicly disclosed by police about the circumstances of her death, while news outlets from around the world have attempted to surmise what might have happened. 

Aug 14, 2025

 

Your support for The East Hampton Star helps us deliver the news, arts, and community information you need. Whether you are an online subscriber, get the paper in the mail, delivered to your door in Manhattan, or are just passing through, every reader counts. We value you for being part of The Star family.

Your subscription to The Star does more than get you great arts, news, sports, and outdoors stories. It makes everything we do possible.