Skip to main content

On the Police Logs 05.05.22

Thu, 05/05/2022 - 09:59


A glider flying too low over the beach led police to search areas near Napeague Lane, Atlantic Avenue, and Indian Wells on the morning of April 25. Bruce Howard reported the low-flying craft at about 8 a.m., but it was not found.

Tyler Mattson was staring out at the ocean midday on April 27 when he spotted flares. Police contacted the Coast Guard at Star Island Station Montauk, and learned the flares were part of a training exercise.

East Hampton

A key component of a seeder — the part that controls the rate of seed distribution — was stolen from the Historical Farm Museum over the weekend of April 16. Brian Carabine estimated its replacement cost at $200.

A Landfall Road resident received a phone call last week purporting to come from Homeland Security, saying that a package of “fake I.D.s and contraband” addressed to her had been intercepted, and to await instructions. Hearing nothing by the next day, she called the federal agency, which said they had not called, and told her to inform local law enforcement of the incident. Luckily, she told police, she had not given the scammer any personal or bank information.

The new director of the LongHouse Reserve, Carrie Barratt, found a number of small cards scattered across the grounds last week with the words “Bring Back Matko” written on them. She told police it was the reserve’s opening day under new leadership, and that there has been some controversy, but that she didn’t know anyone specific who would do such a thing.

East Hampton Village

A Honda with a temporary Texas registration, parked at Wiborg’s Beach on April 26, aroused the suspicion of beachgoers. Someone called police, who made a computer check and found that the car was registered to a 2009 Saturn and that its vehicle identification number was not on file in Texas. It was taken by Hammer Towing to the police impound.

Smoke was pouring from the windows of the bathrooms in the Reutershan parking lot on April 26 when police arrived. Village firefighters, who were already there, determined the cause: a “smoke bomb.” The building was undamaged.


After being out at the Montauket Friday evening, Melissa Schmidt of Port Jefferson returned to the Royal Atlantic around midnight and found loud music coming from a neighbor’s room. She knocked and asked that he turn it down, but he immediately began yelling at her, she told police, and punched her in the arm. Officers arrived and tried to speak with the neighbor, but there was no answer at the door. They told Ms. Schmidt, who said she was not hurt and refused medical attention, to call them if the noise continued and to avoid the neighbor.

The Coast Guard asked for police assistance Saturday afternoon to locate the Peconic Star, an 80-foot-long commercial fishing boat, which was reported to have run

aground about 200 feet off the beach near the Warhol estate. Police found the boat, which was freed in about two hours on a rising tide.

Sag Harbor

A hit-and-run involving a potted plant caused Gregory Brown to call the police to his Hillside Drive West house on April 25. Car tracks on the lawn, found in the morning, showed that the pot had been knocked down overnight. Without surveillance or a license plate, there was little to be done.

Kevin Martin, the groundskeeper at Oakland Cemetery, was outraged to see someone on a red dirt bike riding through the cemetery on the afternoon of April 25, and called police. Officers searched the grounds to no avail.

That evening, Andrea Meyer saw a black Hyundai S.U.V. misjudge a turn from Madison Street onto Union and run over a stop sign, dragging it down the road before driving away. She called police, but the car was long gone.

Jack Spaulding called police from Goldberg’s Bagels on the morning of April 26 because a man was telling employees that the soup was too salty. Police notified the man, who has caused trouble at Goldberg’s before, that he has already been cited for trespass there, and is no longer allowed to enter the store upon pain of arrest.

A passer-by noticed a lighted candle in a closed Washington Street store on the night of April 26 and called police, who left a voice-mail message for the business owner, called a number out front of the store, and found a key in a lockbox that did not open the door. They were unable to get in, and the candle was left to burn down.

Robert Slovack of Brick Kiln Road called last week to complain that two dogs were running amok in his backyard, harassing his cat. Police were able to return the collies, Bella and Bo, to their owners.

An oven exploded at Tutto il Giorno on April 27, and its door burst open, injuring the knee of a cook who was standing nearby. Police told the staff to turn off the gas, and the cook was transported to Stony Brook Southampton Hospital for treatment.

Alan Furst called last Thursday to say he’d found a small cardboard box on his lawn that he believed was intentionally dumped there. Police came and removed the box.

A Honda Pilot, its windows covered with towels and blankets, was parked at Havens Beach very early Sunday morning and someone reported it. A woman in the car told police she’d been working on her computer the night before and fell asleep. She was informed of the overnight beach parking prohibition and moved on.


Loring Bolger called police last week to say that Eastside Court has become an informal dumping area, with beer cans and bottles all strewn about. Ms. Bolger, who heads the Springs Citizens Advisory Committee, said she’d also seen at least four dead deer dumped there recently, and that “they stink to high heaven.” Police found three “actively decaying” deer carcasses and three skeletal remains, just a few feet off the road, and notified the State Department of Environmental Conservation, which promised to follow up.

A smoker started a small brush fire at Victoria Sdrougias’s Gardiner’s Lane property on Saturday morning. By the time the police arrived, Springs firefighters had put out the flames.

Crash Victim Identified as Sag Harbor Woman

The Suffolk County Police Department on Wednesday identified a woman killed in a hit-and-run crash on Monday as Alison Pfefferkorn of Sag Harbor.

Apr 17, 2024

Lieutenant Seeks Damages in New Lawsuit

On March 27, a previously confidential legal document related to an ongoing complaint by Police Officer Andrea Kess against East Hampton Town and its Police Department became public when it was filed in a federal court as evidence in a new civil rights lawsuit, brought by Lt. Peter Powers of the town police. Lieutenant Powers is charging that the document, known as a “position statement,” has harmed his professional and personal reputation.

Apr 11, 2024

Drivers Face Felony Charges

East Hampton Town police have levied felony charges against three drivers on local roads within the last two weeks.

Apr 11, 2024

On the Police Logs 04.11.24

Police responded to the East Hampton I.G.A. shortly after 5 p.m. on April 1 after the manager called in a report of an “unwanted guest.” After an investigation, a 38-year-old man was arrested and charged with two counts of petty larceny: one for taking 24 cans of beer and leaving without paying for them; the other for taking a white Huffy bicycle that did not belong to him. He was released on his own recognizance to await a court date.

Apr 11, 2024

Your support for The East Hampton Star helps us deliver the news, arts, and community information you need. Whether you are an online subscriber, get the paper in the mail, delivered to your door in Manhattan, or are just passing through, every reader counts. We value you for being part of The Star family.

Your subscription to The Star does more than get you great arts, news, sports, and outdoors stories. It makes everything we do possible.