Skip to main content

Gristmill: This Is Their Year

Wed, 11/19/2025 - 12:31
What, no O.J. card? But note among these Buffalo Bills greats QB Jack Kemp, future congressman, presidential candidate, and HUD secretary under the first President Bush.
buffalobills.com

Even in tony Sag Harbor will my battered and sweat-stained Buffalo Bills cap with the dog-tooth bites on the visor elicit “Go Bills!” from pass­ing citizenry. Twice, this was, in a matter of minutes Monday as, with apologies to Grantland Rice, outlined against a blue-gray November sky I strode again . . . into a bank’s lobby.

Safe to say the world of journal­ism has changed since a sportswriter could afford to kick back in an East Hampton estate-district mansion, as Rice did. And his prose was purple.

The Bills are true blue. One of those fellow fans was actually my SUNY Binghamton-educated banker, a school that’s become awfully selective, I couldn’t stop myself from pointing out to him as I went on to explain how my elder daughter’s tenure at college in Gen­eseo in western New York had solidified my amorphous loyalty formation.

His response was apt: “It’s an easy team to like.”

Yes. But why? It can’t simply be that the Jets and Giants play in New Jersey. And it can’t only be Josh Allen, the 6-foot-5, 240-pound quarterback who’s Clark Kent-like in his self-effacing earnestness postgame or in press conferences, and Supermanish with his cannon arm and running back’s legs on the field of play.

This season, my banker, unusual in that his appearance somehow out-Kennedys any Kennedy, has been enthusiastically tracking the juking and hammering backfield exploits of dreadlocked James Cook, now the N.F.L.’s num­ber-two in ground yardage gained.

There’s also something about those die-hard fans and their pro­pensity to voluntarily help shovel Highmark Stadium in the face of lake-effect snow squalls. Or their insistence on donating to the char­ities of players the Bills brutally vanquish.

Or their wit. A recent Bills Mafia lamppost flier making the digital rounds has them begging nearby Toronto’s sports fans to “Please, please stop root­ing for us,” and thus lift the curse that led to a recent loss to the lowly Miami Dolphins, plus two others in a stretch of five games. “And we can’t imagine what that Game 7, eleventh-inning, runner-on-third-with-one-out loss must have felt like,” it continues, piling on about the Blue Jays’ emotional devastation in the World Series just past.

“It’s not us, it’s you. . . . Niagara Falls is already split — that’s done. We’ll take Lake Erie, and you take Lake Ontario.” Visitation weekends for shop­ping purposes will alternate. “Have a great life.”

Hey, whatever it takes to improve the Bills’ juju.

 

Your support for The East Hampton Star helps us deliver the news, arts, and community information you need. Whether you are an online subscriber, get the paper in the mail, delivered to your door in Manhattan, or are just passing through, every reader counts. We value you for being part of The Star family.

Your subscription to The Star does more than get you great arts, news, sports, and outdoors stories. It makes everything we do possible.