Skip to main content

East Hampton Town Fires Code Enforcement Director

Tue, 09/16/2025 - 16:12
Martin Culloton speaking at a Wainscott Citizens Advisory Committee Meeting in May.
Christopher Walsh

In April, the East Hampton Town Board heralded the arrival of Martin Culloton as the new director of code enforcement. On Tuesday, it fired him.

A resolution at the town board's work session Tuesday, read by Councilwoman Cate Rogers, listed his last day of employment as Wednesday, Sept. 17.

Word began to circulate late last week that Mr. Culloton had been involved in a minor altercation with another employee about the use of "flex-time" in his department. 

Phone calls by The Star last Thursday and Friday asking for Mr. Culloton went unreturned.

According to two sources who were in the room, Mr. Culloton grabbed the collar of an employee to move him out of his way; the incident was reported to the Human Resources Department. The employee whose collar was grabbed was not involved in the flex-time argument, the sources said.

A freedom of information request made to the Human Resources Department regarding "disciplinary actions" taken by the town against Mr. Culloton had not been answered by press time.

According to the town's press release from April, before joining East Hampton, Mr. Culloton served as a town investigator in the Code Enforcement Department for the Town of Southampton.

The town has had its share of staffing challenges, specifically losing a number of department heads since the summer of 2024, starting with the departure of Jeremy Samuelson, the town planning director, last August. By the winter of 2025, Eric Schantz, the head of Housing and Community Development, Joseph Palermo, the chief building inspector, Robert Connelly, the town attorney, and Kevin Cooper, the director of Code Enforcement before Mr. Culloton, had all departed.

It was only last week that Mr. Schantz and Mr. Palermo were replaced, highlighting the difficulty of hiring. In fact, on Tuesday, Supervisor Kathee Burke-Gonzalez, speaking about the potential of a Long Island Rail Road strike, said two dozen town employees use the train to commute to work.    

Another employee in the Code Enforcement Department, Aaron Arkinson, submitted a letter of resignation to the town board this week. He has been hired by East Hampton Village and will be a code enforcement officer in its Building Department, a move that will be announced at the village board's Sept. 26 meeting.

Villages

Shades of Wild East in Popular Fishing Tourney

The Mr. Poseidon Montauk Striper Challenge, a fierce competition with a large cash prize, brought hundreds of competitors to the hamlet for a catch-and-release striped bass contest that is touted by its organizer as the “biggest surf fishing tournament on the East Coast.” Critics say it left a trail of problems.

Oct 29, 2026

Whalemen, Shipwrecks, Coded Messages

Atlantic Avenue, which terminates in one of the most seasonally popular beaches in town, was from 1870 to 1918 a working man’s hub focused on the capture of whales. The historical preservationist Robert Hefner detailed this era along with tales of shipwrecks, Nazi saboteurs, and more in a talk last weekend.

Oct 29, 2026

History Still Under Threat

In an increasingly homogenized world, preservation “is what makes places distinct,” Michael Devonshire told the Ladies Village Improvement Society during its 33rd annual Landmarks Luncheon, pointing to “some wonderful local examples of absolute gems that you should all be proud of.”

Oct 29, 2026

 

Your support for The East Hampton Star helps us deliver the news, arts, and community information you need. Whether you are an online subscriber, get the paper in the mail, delivered to your door in Manhattan, or are just passing through, every reader counts. We value you for being part of The Star family.

Your subscription to The Star does more than get you great arts, news, sports, and outdoors stories. It makes everything we do possible.