Word on the street in 2026 tells us that while everyone and their uncle decries that lack of community in these digital times — the fading away of community gatherings, from bowling leagues to knitting circles — fewer residents are taking part when offered the chance to share an in-person community meal: The trend is toward takeout.
Whether it is the Rotary Club’s annual spaghetti and meatballs supper at the East Hampton American Legion Post 419 in Amagansett, the Calvary Baptist Church chicken and ribs barbecue each summer on Spinner Lane in East Hampton, or corned beef and cabbage on St. Patrick’s Day at the Springs Community Church, most stakeholders say that fewer participants are pulling up a chair and joining the common table. The food is eaten at home out of a takeaway box.
This Thanksgiving, the organizers of the community Thanksgiving Day meal, held every November in the Session House of the Presbyterian church in East Hampton, are attempting to do something about it. Last year, according to the Rev. Jon Rodriguez, 107 free meals were served, but only 40 of them were to those seated in the cheerfully decorated fellowship hall; the rest were driven off to be eaten at home. Thanksgiving, especially, should be about gathering together, said Mr. Rodriguez.
The community lunch “allows our church to tangibly express our spiritual values,” Mr. Rodriguez said. “We talk a lot about creating a community where all are welcome, provided for, and respected, and this meal empowers us to do just that. At the table, you’re given the opportunity to meet fellow members of our town and bond over the shared value of community. You can get an excellent takeout meal from plenty of other places, but this is the only meal that comes with good company and fellowship.”
To encourage participants to stay and eat together, invitation cards have been printed up for volunteers to hand out to anyone who might need a place to go or who might simply enjoy the warmth of the occasion.
The free annual community Thanksgiving has been held at the Presbyterian church since the 1980s, when it was started by the Community Council, according to Kristy LaMonda, who has been volunteering since she was a teenager and serves as a major domo on the big day.
This year, the organization is, itself, a community affair. It is running off the elbow grease of volunteers from three churches: Calvary Baptist has offered a mountain of green beans and catering supplies, as well as expertise based on members’ many decades dishing up fund-raising meals; congregation members at St. Luke’s Episcopal Church are the official turkey wranglers, donating a dozen birds and storing them in their capacious freezer, and East Hampton Presbyterian church members are preparing stuffing and other sides; the youth group is baking caramel-apple pies.
“Over the years, we have provided fellowship for a wide variety of folks,” said Ms. LaMonda, who lives in East Hampton Village. “Seniors, exchange students, teachers from abroad, and families who weren’t able to make a large dinner themselves. This is not an income-based soup kitchen — it is a meal open to anyone.”
The meal is served at round tables festively decorated for the season with autumn wreaths and flowers, each table seating seven to 10 diners.
On Friday, notice was posted on Facebook that not enough cooks had come forward yet; by Monday, according to Mr. Rodriguez, a flood of cooks had stepped in.
The ante has been upped. In addition to nearly 20 home cooks who are tying on their aprons, Share the Harvest Farm is donating sweet-potato soup as a starter. Round Swamp Farm (which also provides a Thanksgiving meal to the East Hampton Town Senior Citizens Center) called to offer cauliflower gratin, brussels sprouts, and tri-berry pies. Smokin’ Wolf is donating mashed potatoes and sweet potatoes.
Of course, East Hampton is home to many who cannot get out to a community gathering such as this. And so, as has been the tradition since the late 1990s, volunteer drivers from Meals on Wheels of East Hampton will be picking up takeout bags for homebound clients (each bag decorated by school-aged volunteer artists).
Christina DeSanti of Meals on Wheels pointed out that the caterers who provide daily meals to clients only take off three days a year: Thanksgiving, Christmas, and New Year’s. This leaves a gap in the schedule that they are grateful is filled by this annual volunteer effort. “Some of our people don’t have family nearby and are very happy to have a friendly face come to the door on Thanksgiving,” Ms. DeSanti said.
Those interested in helping out on Thanksgiving Day have been asked to contact the Presbyterian church in advance by calling that office at 631-324-0711 or sending an email to [email protected], rather than showing up unannounced, to help the operation run smoothly.
Seating in the hall can accommodate about 75 guests. The organizers hope that, this year, the trend will be bucked and the seats all filled.