On Monday, the Suffolk County Sheriff’s Department quietly evicted HeliFlite, a private helicopter charter service, from the Executive Terminal of the East Hampton Town Airport at 50 Industrial Road.
It appeared that the company had already departed, ahead of the official eviction.
“If they’re actually closing the Executive Terminal, that’s a small but good thing,” said Barry Raebeck of the Coalition to Transform East Hampton Airport, via text, on Monday afternoon. “It would be the only positive change at the airport in memory.”
However, a closure is likely not the case.
Patrick Derenze, the town’s public information officer, said, “The supervisor has a number of different uses in mind that she is working through with town staff. She will bring this to the town board in the new year.”
The ultimate eviction of Heliflite came after a long legal struggle between the town and the estates of Ben and Bonnie Krupinski over the sublease for the terminal. It took hearings in front of many courts and judges, and more than five years, before East Hampton Town finally emerged victorious.
The case is a little complicated.
Before HeliFlite occupied the terminal, Long Island Airlines, a limited liability company owned by the late Ben and Bonnie Krupinski, used the facility.
The Krupinskis signed a 20-year lease for the terminal in 1997 and renewed it for 10 years in 2016, but died in a plane crash off Indian Wells Beach in 2018. (Their grandson William Maerov and the pilot of the plane, Jon Dollard, also died in the accident, brought on by a severe thunderstorm.)
After the crash, Long Island Airlines had no principals and its equipment was sold; he company had been owned equally by the estate of Ben Krupinski and the estate of Bonnie Krupinski. At the start of litigation, representatives of the company admitted its only asset was the lease.
What was that lease worth? If they could find a subletter that the town agreed to, the lease could still bring money to the estates.
For the first 11 years, the Krupinskis paid between $50,000 and $67,000 annually for the use of the terminal. After that, they were to pay “the then-prevailing rate for hangar space and terminal/office space at the town airport,” the lease stated.
According to the lawsuit, Long Island Airlines tried to sublet the property to Jimmy Buffet, the singer-songwriter, who maintained a home in Sag Harbor. However, a court ruled that L.I.A. had become a company in name only and that the town could void the lease.
After Mr. Buffet left the equation, the combined estates sought to assign the lease to Sound Aircraft Services, which is the other long-time fixed-base operator at the airport.
The Federal Aviation Administration defines an F.B.O. as “a commercial business granted the right by the airport sponsor to operate on an airport and provide aeronautical services such as fueling, hangaring, tie-down and parking, aircraft rental, aircraft maintenance, and flight instruction.”
However, the estates alleged that the town breached the lease by “unreasonably withholding its consent” for L.I.A. to assign the lease. For its part, in 2021 the town accused L.I.A. of violating “obligations of your tenancy” by not maintaining the facilities. Further, the town said, L.I.A. could not sublet the property without the town’s approval.
Long Island Airlines called that argument a “sham” and said it was all part of a town conspiracy to shut the airport, according to court papers.
At some point, around 2020, Heliflite started using the terminal, operating under L.I.A.’s contested lease, and it began paying for litigation against the town, using L.I.A.’s lawyer. This arrangement was never approved by a court, however, and it is not clear if the company ever paid the town for using the hangar and facilities.
If the town was awarded monetary damages for its inability to lease the site, it did not disclose that number.
“For five years, the town’s former tenant and HeliFlite have gone from court to court trying to stop the town from recovering its own hangar after L.I.A. materially breached its lease,” Nick Rigano, a partner at Rigano L.L.C. and outside counsel for the town, wrote in a statement sent through Mr. Derenze. “Every state and federal court that heard the case ultimately ruled for the town. On Monday, the town took back public property under a lawful court order.”
Supervisor Kathee Burke-Gonzalez issued a similar statement through Mr. Derenze.
While it will not impact airport operations, the removal of a charter-helicopter service may mean a quieter tenant may eventually use the space — or not. HeliFlite can still use the main airport terminal.
The Executive Terminal is on the south side of the airport property, nearer to Industrial Road and closest to a residential neighborhood. HeliFlite apparently did a lot of “hot loading” (landing helicopters but keeping the blades running while unloading and boarding passengers).
“It was a source of additional noise for neighbors as aircraft idle there,” said Mr. Raebeck.
Jim Brundige, the airport director, declined to speak with The Star. “I’m to refer media folks to the town board for comments and questions,” he wrote in a text.
When asked if Sound Aircraft Services is interested in acquiring the lease, Bernadette Ruggiero, its chief financial officer, said via text, “I am sure the town board will consider the various options with care and consideration towards its constituents. To be continued.”