Skip to main content

Item of the Week: The 1964 Edwards Theater Fire

Thu, 04/10/2025 - 12:40

From the East Hampton Library’s Long Island Collection

In the early morning of April 14, 1964, East Hampton Village police were notified of smoke emerging from the Edwards Theater. Sgt. Joseph Loris (1927-2001) alerted the East Hampton Fire Department, and firefighters arrived to see smoke pouring out of the building, signaling a much more serious fire within.

The firemen entered the theater to assess the situation and realized that the flames originated from above the lobby ceiling and under the theater seats. After several failed attempts at taming the blaze from inside, they exited the building, determined to put out the fire externally. This photograph from The East Hampton Star’s archive shows firemen fighting flames hidden behind the theater’s facade.

That fight was short-lived, as the fire broke through the roof and traveled to the rear of the building. Despite the firemen’s efforts to hose down the conflagration, the roof of the theater collapsed, and soon the southwest and northeast walls fell. Clearly there would be no showing of the advertised “Captain Newman, M.D.” at the Edwards Theater that night.

The fire was extinguished after several hours with aid from neighboring fire departments. The theater and several other businesses within the building, such as the Marmador restaurant, A.C. Osborne Jewelry, and the surveying office of Geoffrey Bass (1902-1965), were destroyed.

The fire was caused by faulty wiring under the theater seats. The damage to all five businesses in the building was estimated at around half a million dollars at the time, or around $5 million today. Although other businesses in the building relocated, Herman Ficken, the eastern Suffolk district manager of the Prudential Theaters chain, promised that the theater would be reconstructed in the same location.

Ficken’s promise came true in the summer of 1965, when Leonard Edwards (1899-1975), son of the theater’s founder, LeRoy Edwards (1875-1947), opened the East Hampton Theater. Since then, the building has been expanded and renovated into the current five-screen Regal UA theater on Main Street.

Megan Bardis is a librarian and archivist in the Long Island Collection.

Villages

Amistad Week Comes Ashore

Amistad Week, commemorating the slave ship that was seized off Montauk in 1839 and featuring a series of events in the hamlet dedicated to history, art, and community, begins next week.

Aug 21, 2025

Remembering Gosman’s Dock

A new book — “Memories of Gosman’s Dock, by the Help” — is a love letter to the local institution Gosman’s used to be, before it changed ownership last fall.

Aug 21, 2025

Item of the Week: When the Hampton Classic Was in East Hampton

Did you know East Hampton once hosted the Hampton Classic Horse Show? This Dan Rattiner map shows the layout at Dune Alpin Farm in 1979.

Aug 21, 2025

 

Your support for The East Hampton Star helps us deliver the news, arts, and community information you need. Whether you are an online subscriber, get the paper in the mail, delivered to your door in Manhattan, or are just passing through, every reader counts. We value you for being part of The Star family.

Your subscription to The Star does more than get you great arts, news, sports, and outdoors stories. It makes everything we do possible.