Skip to main content

Item of the Week: In the Old Sag Harbor Jail

Thu, 09/05/2024 - 11:52

From the East Hampton Library’s Long Island Collection

It’s all fun and games until someone gets arrested. For residents of Sag Harbor, an offense of sufficient seriousness could land a person in the village jail.

Many small towns and villages did not have official jails until the latter half of the 18th century or the beginning of the 19th. In a post-Civil War America, an effort to rebuild and shore up the country’s institutions gained traction, leading to the repair of old penitentiaries and the construction of many new ones.

The jail pictured here was built in Sag Harbor in 1916. The contractor, George Garypie, was paid a tidy sum of $1,259.90, or about $36,600 today. Garypie was in charge of the carpentry, and the steel prison cells were handled by the E.T. Barnum Wire and Iron Works of Detroit for $555.90, about $16,000 now. The building was used from 1916 all the way until 1983, when a new holding cell was built inside the adjacent Sag Harbor Police Department headquarters.

Cells in the building were used to hold prisoners only temporarily, but it never took long for the occupants to engage in skullduggery. According to research by Jean Held, a former Sag Harbor Historical Society board member, many people recalled smuggling alcohol to friends imprisoned in the cells using rubber tubing or simply by handing containers through the windows.

Four years after closing, the jailhouse had fallen into disrepair, as can be seen in this Firth Calhoun photograph from The East Hampton Star’s archive. In an effort to save the building, Sag Harbor Village officials offered it to the newly formed historical society as a potential headquarters. The society agreed to restore the jail, although the group now has a separate headquarters building and runs the jail as a small museum.


Julia Tyson is a librarian and archivist in the East Hampton Library’s Long Island Collection.

Villages

A New Idea for More Affordable Housing

Two recent architecture and engineering grads who pitched a scalable housing solution for Sag Harbor received an enthusiastic reception from the village board.

Sep 11, 2025

Professional Problem-Solver Manages It All

John Trentacoste of East Hampton has spent the last 20 years as a professional property management problem-solver. The work is varied, complex, and unending.

Sep 11, 2025

Secret’s Out on Cinema’s $5 Mystery Movies

Imagine walking into the movies, buying popcorn, and waiting for your movie to start, but there’s a catch — you don’t know what will play. Such is Regal’s Monday Mystery Movies at the East Hampton Cinema.

Sep 11, 2025

 

Your support for The East Hampton Star helps us deliver the news, arts, and community information you need. Whether you are an online subscriber, get the paper in the mail, delivered to your door in Manhattan, or are just passing through, every reader counts. We value you for being part of The Star family.

Your subscription to The Star does more than get you great arts, news, sports, and outdoors stories. It makes everything we do possible.