Skip to main content

John Leo McGuirk Jr., 89

Thu, 07/23/2020 - 12:35

John Leo McGuirk Jr. enjoyed a good party and "welcomed anybody and everybody" to his front porch on the corner of McGuirk Street and Newtown Lane in East Hampton Village, "especially on Friday nights," his children said.

Mr. McGuirk died of heart failure at home on July 2. He was 89 and had been in declining health.

The only child of Florence Raynor McGuirk and John Leo McGuirk Sr., he was born at Southampton Hospital on Oct. 22, 1930, and grew up in the house at Newtown Lane and McGuirk Street, where he spent most of his life.

Mr. McGuirk's history on the South Fork runs deep. He was an 11th-generation descendant of Thurston Raynor, an early settler of Southampton, and a descendant of James E. Gay of East Hampton. His house in East Hampton was built as a boarding house by his grandmother Mary Ellen Gay McGuirk.

Mr. McGuirk married Kathryn McGuire, whom he had met in the eighth grade, on Jan. 16, 1954, at St. Philomena's Church in East Hampton, now Most Holy Trinity Catholic Church. Like him, their children were raised on the corner of McGuirk Street and Newtown Lane, in the house that has now been home to five generations of the McGuirk family.

His oldest son, Patrick, died in 1963. He is survived by his son John McGuirk III of East Hampton and his daughters Susan McGuirk of East Hampton, Sandra Kalke of Mooresville, N.C., Barbara Tracey of East Hampton, and Mary Ellen Hess of Windermere, Fla. His wife died in 2018.

"He loved a big family," his children said this week. "He loved having people around." His children's friends and grandchildren's friends were always welcomed at his house. "He was very accepting of people."

Mr. McGuirk was a lifelong member of Most Holy Trinity Church and a 71-year member of the East Hampton Fire Department. In his earlier years, he enjoyed being on the Fire Department's tournament teams. He served in the Air Force from 1951 to 1955 and in the Korean War. He was a sergeant and was stationed in Biloxi, Miss., Okinawa, Japan, and Denver. His time in the service was the only time when he did not live in East Hampton.

In addition to his children, Mr. McGuirk is survived by 11 grandchildren — Elizabeth Peterson, Bridget Haney, Amy Rumore, Caitlin Kalke, Alexander Kalke, Shannon Tracey, Christopher Tracey, Meghan Hess, Kathryn Hess, John McGuirk IV, and Patrick McGuirk — and by seven great-grandsons.

A graveside service was held on July 7 at Most Holy Trinity Cemetery on Cedar Street, with the Rev. Ryan Creamer officiating.

His family has suggested memorial contributions to the East Hampton Fire Department, 1 Cedar Street, East Hampton 11937, or East End Hospice, P.O. Box 1048, Westhampton Beach 11978.

Villages

Springs Food Pantry Sees the Need, Addresses It

The last few years have presented challenges the Springs Food Pantry’s founders could not have anticipated when it was first established. More than 600 families are now registered to receive the assistance it provides, and an average of 355 families are served each week.

Jun 26, 2025

A Newsletter on Being a Jew in Today’s America

One of the essential roles of religion, Rabbi Jan Uhrbach of the Bridge Shul in Bridgehampton said this week, is to “help us hold onto our humanity, and remind us of the higher values that go beyond money and power and position and all of those things, in a time when the values that I hold dear are not only being violated, they’re being rejected as values.”

Jun 26, 2025

Item of the Week: The Hemerocallis Garden, 1962

Hemerocallis may be an unfamiliar term, but the garden adjacent to Clinton Academy once bore the name. This photo shows the gate to the garden some two decades after its establishment in 1941.

Jun 26, 2025

 

Your support for The East Hampton Star helps us deliver the news, arts, and community information you need. Whether you are an online subscriber, get the paper in the mail, delivered to your door in Manhattan, or are just passing through, every reader counts. We value you for being part of The Star family.

Your subscription to The Star does more than get you great arts, news, sports, and outdoors stories. It makes everything we do possible.