Skip to main content

Potter Makes His Case for a Parking Lot

Thu, 11/19/2026 - 11:02
The so-called “gas ball lot” in Sag Harbor Village has been much disputed and discussed.
Christine Sampson

Adam Potter’s lawyer asked Sag Harbor Village officials this week to choose one of two paths in order to keep the property at 5 Bridge Street, known as the “gas ball” lot, a parking lot.

Mr. Potter has a 99-year lease with National Grid on the property but is allowing the village to use the lot as municipal paid parking during a transitional phase. After that, it will return back to Mr. Potter’s private use. The lot has only been used for parking since the gas ball was removed in 2007 and would require some form of relief to remain a parking lot, according to Tiffany Scarlato, Mr. Potter’s attorney.

The question facing the zoning board of appeals is whether the relief will be in the form of an appeal of a building inspector’s determination or, barring that, a rarely approved use variance.

The Z.B.A. review of the gas ball lot looks at only a piece of a larger project proposed by Mr. Potter, who is planning a redevelopment of three lots on Bridge Street. In addition to 5 Bridge Street, Mr. Potter owns 7 and 11 Bridge Street, and is planning to tear down the existing buildings there and construct a three-story, 81,000-square-foot building with around 50,000 square feet devoted to housing. He is planning 28 units to sell at market rate and 20 affordable units. On the first floor, 8,500 square feet would be set aside for service-use commercial space. Forty-four parking spaces on numbers 7 and 11 Bridge Street have also been proposed.

The gas ball lot would hold 93 parking spaces to service the new building.

The planning board, which is the lead agency on review of the larger project, is wrapping up its analysis of a final environmental impact statement and is required to issue its findings in the next week. Mr. Potter is seeking several approvals from the planning board, including a special-exception approval to allow apartments in the office district and to build a structure larger than 3,500 square feet in the waterfront overlay district. 

In addition, results of a public hearing and review of a cleanup plan on 7 and 11 Bridge Street with the state’s Department of Environmental Conservation are pending. 

All three lots are known to be contaminated with coal tar from their historical use as a gas-manufacturing plant beginning in the 19th century. The gas ball lot, however, is not subject to the current D.E.C. cleanup plan, as the cleanup there was undertaken by National Grid and completed after it was designated a federal Superfund site.

Mr. Potter signed a long-term lease with National Grid, which stipulated that the property could only be used as a parking lot; any other use would require the power company’s approval and would likely not be permitted. A building on the site would require further extensive environmental remediation.

Because of this, 5 Bridge Street is unique, a factor the Z.B.A. needs to consider when applying its standards for a use variance, Ms. Scarlato said. “This was not a hardship created by the applicant,” she said.

However, while National Grid may believe a parking lot is the most suitable use for the property, the former building inspector determined that a parking lot on land without a primary structure is not permitted, even while a parking lot is a permitted use in the office district where the gas ball lot is located. 

Ms. Scarlato’s argument is that a footnote in the use table indicates that the definitions therein are “for informational purposes only” and would not preclude the use of the property for stand-alone parking. 

“That footnote matters,” Ms. Scarlato said on Tuesday night. While the use table outlines specifics on how much parking is required, it does not go into detail on whether it needs to share a property with a primary use. Ms. Scarlato referred to this as an ambiguity.

“When there is an ambiguity . . . it is resolved in favor of a property owner,” she said, adding that the board should “enforce the text as written.”

The Z.B.A. took a backseat to the planning board this week, declining to comment on Ms. Scarlato’s presentation while that board’s state environmental quality review is pending. Legally, the Z.B.A. cannot close the hearing until the SEQRA review is complete. Once the planning board makes its determination, the Z.B.A. can follow suit.

While multiple applications move through the pipeline, Mr. Potter has also filed suit against some members of the Sag Harbor Village Board, the planning board, and the Z.B.A. Mr. Potter has accused them of violating his constitutional right to equal protection and is seeking $25 million in damages. In the paperwork, Mr. Potter said emails indicate a conspiracy to keep his project from advancing.

Last week, the attorney representing him in that matter, Alex Kriegsman, said he had obtained emails between village officials and the group Save Sag Harbor that he believes are inappropriate. The civic group has mobilized some residents to publicly denounce Mr. Potter’s redevelopment. Among those messages, he said, are communications from some board members reviewing the project and a planning board member who had recused herself earlier in the application process. Mr. Kriegsman said a recused board member is “precluded from discussing the project entirely.”

That case, originally filed in state court, has been moved to federal court.

The planning board meets on Wednesday to continue its review of the project.

Villages

Patriots’ Gravestones Get Much-Needed Care

In December of last year, the town board resolved to spend up to $6,800 to celebrate the nation’s 250th anniversary by preserving Revolutionary War-era gravestones.

Nov 19, 2026

A Run in Memory of John Keeshan

Montauk’s 50th annual Turkey Trot Run for Fun, a tradition founded by John Keeshan in 1976, gets underway on Thanksgiving Day at 10 a.m. The run is the first since Keeshan died in January.  

Nov 19, 2026

An Invitation to Gather for Thanksgiving

The organizers of the Thanksgiving Day meal held yearly in the Session House of the East Hampton Presbyterian Church are attempting to do something about the lack of communal meals and the rise of takeout.

Nov 19, 2026

 

Your support for The East Hampton Star helps us deliver the news, arts, and community information you need. Whether you are an online subscriber, get the paper in the mail, delivered to your door in Manhattan, or are just passing through, every reader counts. We value you for being part of The Star family.

Your subscription to The Star does more than get you great arts, news, sports, and outdoors stories. It makes everything we do possible.