Skip to main content

Once a Busboy, Soon the Owner

Once a Busboy, Soon the Owner

“If people want crazy froufrou cuisine, they can go to other places,” according to Sami Krasniqi, left, who is taking over Cafe Max from Max and Nancy Weintraub.
“If people want crazy froufrou cuisine, they can go to other places,” according to Sami Krasniqi, left, who is taking over Cafe Max from Max and Nancy Weintraub.
Morgan McGivern
What Cafe Max customers do demand is fish, and lots of it, “very moist and very fresh,” purchased directly from Gosman’s in Montauk
By
Debra Scott

    After 23 years at the helm of Cafe Max, Max Weintraub has turned over the wheel to Sami Krasniqi, who began his restaurant career at the iconic eatery as a dishwasher two weeks after it opened. But not much, if anything, has changed. Mr. Weintraub is still involved from afar and has inked a deal with Mr. Krasniqi in which the two share in profits.

    “I don’t want to be intrusive,” Mr. Weintraub said last week on one of his few recent visits to the restaurant that he and his wife, Nancy, tended for so long. Mr. Weintraub occasionally shows up to butcher meat or answer questions the new proprietor might have about maintenance or insurance.

    One thing Mr. Krasniqi doesn’t need help with is cooking. He worked his way up over the years, doing just about any job necessary, from busboy to runner, till finally becoming Mr. Weintraub’s sous chef.

    Mr. Krasniqi emigrated here from Kosovo and was introduced to the Weintraubs by his uncle, Tasim Kastrati, the longtime maitre d’ at Gordon’s in Amagansett.

    After experimenting with a change in menu once he took over last winter, Mr. Krasniqi said, he “was put in my place by my customers who don’t want any change.” He tried “to freshen it up with a little Mediterranean” but found that the clientele balked at “too much spice or esoteric cooking.”

    The customer base is made up of a mix of Maidstone Club members, who have followed Mr. Weintraub since he was a sous chef there after graduating from the Culinary Institute of America, and former patrons of Mr. Weintraub’s restaurant at the Maidstone Arms, which he ran in the 1980s.

    What Cafe Max customers do demand is fish, and lots of it, “very moist and very fresh,” purchased directly from Gosman’s in Montauk. Mr. Krasniqi buys a few pieces of many varieties — up to 15 kinds at any time, from gray sole to swordfish to striped bass. He’d rather “run out of something” than serve a dish that wasn’t straight off a boat.

    The kitchen is gearing up for scallop season, which begins Monday. “That first week we do more than 60 percent in scallops,” said Mr. Krasniqi, who is happy to prepare them any style a customer desires — plain, in garlic and oil or a beurre blanc, deep fried, Provencal. “If we have the ingredients, we accommodate.” And that goes for the preparation of other fish. “So far I haven’t said no to anyone.”

    “If people want crazy froufrou cuisine, they can go to other places,” Mr. Krasniqi said. Indeed, a decade ago when a Zagat’s diner declared the restaurant to be “unHamptons,” the moniker stuck, and Mr. Krasniqi’s apron is emblazoned with it.

    He once received some sage advice from a marketing man: “If you can’t describe your restaurant in one sentence, you’re going to fail.” His description is of a no-frills seafood joint that provides comfort food to locals. And, of course, weekenders.

    Leonard Goodman, who was eating dinner there last week, remarked that he has followed Mr. Weintraub for more than 30 years. “We always come when we’re out; we gravitate to a place that feels like home,” he said, also referring to the “warmth” generated by the cedar-clad walls, the intimate dimensions of the 44-seat space, and the welcoming staff.

    Continuing in an unpretentious vein, Mr. Krasniqi declared, “We don’t raise the prices in summer the way most places do.” Like many restaurants that stay open in the off-season, Cafe Max offers a heavily discounted prix fixe menu. Even on Friday nights, $18 gets diners a two-course meal. “As much as food costs are going through the roof,” said Mr. Krasniqi, “we still want to offer our customer value.”

    Mr. Krasniqi is grateful to have been handed the reins. While Mr. Weintraub could have gone with another chef, he knew “that I wasn’t going to change” the formula. Then there’s the familial factor. “Max is like a father to me,” he said of his mentor. “There’s an enormous amount of trust.”

    Mr. Krasniqi has followed Mr. Weintraub in more ways than one. In 2007 the younger chef left Cafe Max to take over the kitchen at the Maidstone Arms, where Mr. Weintraub had worked 20 years before. When the new owner purchased the inn, she bought out Mr. Krasniqi’s lease, as had happened to Mr. Weintraub a generation prior. He then went on to open Andrra, a Mediterranean-style boite in Springs, before selling his share to his brother.

    As for the Weintraubs, “We miss it,” said Nancy, who ran the front of the house and bought the wine for which the restaurant received 10 Wine Spectator Awards. “We never had children; this was our baby in a way.”

    Yet, for Max, after years of toil he’s content now with a simple routine of going to the gym and doing yard work. Even reading the newspaper is a new pleasure, something that his long days in the kitchen didn’t allow. When he does come into his creation, he gazes around proudly at what he built. These days the children of his former Maidstone Club patrons are bringing in their families.

East End Eats: Winter Spin on a Summer Space

East End Eats: Winter Spin on a Summer Space

Nammo’s interior benefits from a previous renovation that opened up the low ceilings and small rooms of the old Post House restaurant. A generous installation of art doesn’t hurt either.
Nammo’s interior benefits from a previous renovation that opened up the low ceilings and small rooms of the old Post House restaurant. A generous installation of art doesn’t hurt either.
Jennifer Landes
A big, beautiful, airy restaurant situated in the Old Post House in Southampton
By
Laura Donnelly

Nammo’s Estiatoria

136 Main Street

Southampton

287-5500

Dinner nightly, closed Mondays

    Nammo’s Estiatoria is a big, beautiful, airy restaurant situated in the Old Post House in Southampton. It was most recently Nello’s Summertime, but may be better known as a summer season disco and lounge. Indeed, there are lots of private cabanas on the back porch and a disco closed off from the main restaurant at this sleepier time of year. The main room — white with accents of Aegean blue here and there — is huge, two stories high with lots of windows and work by various local artists on the walls. The owners are making a go of staying open all winter and have lowered the prices and streamlined the menu. God bless ’em, I wish them the best of luck, but a few things need to be worked on, first and foremost the food.

    On a recent visit, my friends and I were the only guests in the restaurant so we chose a cozy corner by a fireplace. The only other people in Nammo’s were the chef from Old Stove Pub, and another fellow with whom he had shared a mutual birthday the night before. Their posture and mumbled conversation suggested it was an awesome birthday celebration. Other than those gentlemen, it was just us, and Emilio, who paid so much attention to us I could have married him on the spot.

    Emilio had been playing mixologist recently so we tried two of his new specialty cocktails. One was a hot cider with a bit of Ya Mastiha, a Greek liqueur made from the sap of mastic trees. The other was a refreshing fresh lime juice martini topped with micro-planed lime zest.

    The meal began with a delicious platter of nicely toasted pita triangles, a dish of fruity olive oil, and a cream cheese and roasted red pepper dip. It was delicious. For appetizers, we chose a broccoli salad, calamari, and meatballs. The broccoli salad was a tasty surprise. The little florets were just blanched, then dressed in a sweet-tart dressing with golden raisins, strips of red and yellow peppers, and pancetta bacon. The pancetta was actually regular smoked bacon but the whole combination was excellent and light. The calamari was also very good, with a light and crisp crust surrounding still-tender calamari. This was served with the same cream cheese red pepper dip. The beef meatballs were also very good, three fairly large, fluffy, and well-seasoned meatballs with a simple homemade tomato sauce. The menu said they were served with a yogurt balsamic dressing but we didn’t detect any. They had a hint of mint in them, just about the only Greek accent up to that point.

    For entrees we ordered the grouper, braised lamb pappardelle, and chicken souvlaki. I had hoped for a classic Greek whole fish simply prepared with olive oil and lemon but Emilio insisted the last piece of “fresh” fish in the kitchen was, in fact, not. Sadly, the grouper was a bland square of fish. The side dishes were far better, a light slaw of thinly sliced fennel with dill and lemon and a superb green apple and celery root puree. The braised lamb pappardelle had good flavor, but the pasta was pre-al dente, a bit chewy and undercooked. The chicken souvlaki (marinated chicken on skewers) was overcooked and a bit dry. The lemon potato served with it was good, though. There were a few other entrees that sounded more Italian and American than Greek, a wild mushroom pasta with truffle oil, and a heritage pork chop with asparagus.

    Prices at Nammo’s are very reasonable. Appetizers are $8 to $12, entrees are $16 to $25, sides are $7, and desserts are $7 and $8.

    There are currently only two desserts on the menu, baklava and loukoumades, but Emilio had an extra special one he gave us, leftover from a previous party. The baklava was excellent, although served ice cold from the fridge. It had a good balance of walnuts and pistachios, the phyllo crust was still crisp and the honey syrup very floral and cinnamony. The loukoumades (little round Greek donuts) were also great, warm and yeasty with a drizzle of more honey and a dainty scoop of vanilla cinnamon ice cream. The extra treat was chocolate mousse served in a martini glass. It, too, was very good, creamy and rich.

    I wish very much for Nammo’s to succeed in the off-season. It is a beautiful space with a manager who truly cares. I wish there were a few more Greek offerings (taramasalata, haloumi, moussaka!), and I wish the kitchen cared as much as Emilio does. Most of all, I wish them good luck.

News for Foodies: 10.31.13

News for Foodies: 10.31.13

Local Food News
By
Joanne Pilgrim

    Long Island Restaurant Week begins on Sunday. For a week, through Nov. 10, participating restaurants will be offering $27.95 prix fixe menus. The special will be offered all night each night, except on Saturday, when it will be available only until 7 p.m. It will include a choice from at least three appetizers, three entrees, and three desserts.

    Among the local eateries that are participating are Almond in Bridgehampton, Noah’s in Greenport, the 1770 House and the Living Room in East Hampton, and the Bell and Anchor in Sag Harbor.

    A full list, spanning the entire island, can be found at longislandrestaurantweek.com. Last year, there were 248 restaurants to choose from.

World Cuisine

    At Fresh in Bridgehampton, each Thursday brings an opportunity to visit a different culinary region through a three-course prix fixe prepared by Todd Jacobs, the chef, between 5 and 8 p.m. The special costs $34 per person, plus tax and gratuity.

Holiday Treats

    The Springs General Store has a lineup of homemade Halloween treats, from handmade cookies and Yummy Mummy cake pops, to hot chocolate mixes with homemade marshmallows.

    La Fondita in Amagansett will celebrate Dia de los Muertos, or Day of the Dead, tomorrow and Saturday with menu specials including pork tamales in salsa roja, chile and cheese tamales, turkey in red mole sauce, and a salsa-dipped chorizo and potato sandwich. All can be ordered alone or with a side of rice and refried beans. A traditional Day of the Dead drink, atole de pina, a warm porridge beverage with pineapple, will also be available.

    La Fondita is currently open during lunch and dinner hours on Wednesday through Sunday.

Rowdyween Halloween

    Rowdy Hall will have its 14th annual Rowdyween party tonight from 8 p.m. to midnight. Those attending must come in costume, and can enter into a contest for $500 in prizes awarded for the best Halloween get-ups. A $30 admission fee will include one drink and passed hors d’oeuvres. There will be drink specials and a D.J. spinning tunes.

New, Scandinavian

    Mathias Brogie, the chef at the Living Room at c/o the Maidstone inn in East Hampton, has added some new Scandinavian-inspired dishes to the menu. They include, as starters, pumpkin blinis, button mushroom soup with smoked eel, herring with egg, brown butter, and dill sautéed potatoes, blackened gravlax “pastrami” served with pumpkin chutney, and foie gras tacos.

    As entrees, flounder meuniere, grilled monkfish, pan-fried Arctic char, crispy duck breast, venison, and biff rydberg, a Nordic beef dish, are available.

At Indian Wells

    Indian Wells Tavern in Amagansett will host a fund-raiser on Monday from 6 to 10 p.m. for the East Hampton High School Camerata singing group, which is raising money for a spring trip to Italy. There will be a cash bar, passed hors d’oeuvres, and a silent auction. Admission is $20.

Seasons by the Sea: Martha Came Calling

Seasons by the Sea: Martha Came Calling

Lemon fig cake is one of the simple and easy-to-execute recipes included in Martha Stewart’s “Cakes.”
Lemon fig cake is one of the simple and easy-to-execute recipes included in Martha Stewart’s “Cakes.”
It is a very good book, well illustrated with recipes ranging from simple coffee cakes to a more elaborate chocolate truffle cake
By
Laura Donnelly

    This is the saga of an attempt to get an interview to publicize a cookbook for the benefit of an author who approached The East Hampton Star for said story in the first place.

Martha Stewart, or more accurately, the editors at Martha Stewart Living have published a book called “Cakes.” It is a very good book, well illustrated with recipes ranging from simple coffee cakes to a more elaborate chocolate truffle cake. There are bundt, tube, cheese, and layer cakes. Some recipes are charmingly old-fashioned, such as the blueberry buckle, and some are modern and more sophisticated like the Meyer lemon coffee cake and blackberry cornmeal cake. There are some gluten-free recipes and a few that can be converted to kosher for Passover. The illustrations for techniques are very user-friendly, not intimidating at all. Ingredients and technique are so important in baking and this book is very thorough and helpful in listing the best of the former and easiest of the latter.

    Given the choice between an actual interview or an e-mail-submitted interview, any journalist will take the real-time interview. It is spontaneous and more revealing. One question or answer can serendipitously lead to another and so on. E-mail answers to questions can often be a bit stilted, too literate, just not the same. So I was delighted that Martha’s people offered mea 15-minute interview over the phone.

    With some fairly innocuous, softball questions at the ready, I eagerly awaited the appointed time, 2 to 2:15 p.m., but with an open window until 3 on a Monday in September. A friend called me earlier in the day. “Your interview will probably be canceled! Have you seen today’s Page Six of the New York Post?!” No, I hadn’t, I don’t read that crap, but that day I did. Indeed there was a snippy item at the top of the page about Martha and a tawdry alleged affair with a married fellow in East Hampton and blah, blah, blah. At 2 p.m. on the dot, my interview was canceled. This was distressing to me, as I had traveled into the city that day, blown off a lunch date with my only child, and scheduled a much later Jitney bus to accommodate the timing of the interview with Martha Stewart.

    Her people were very apologetic and assured me it would be rescheduled. It never was, but then they/she agreed to an e-mail interview. I submitted my fun questions. Long story short, three more deadlines were missed. My editors and I gave up completely and moved on. Then, out of the blue, came a reply. It appeared that Martha had cherry picked through my questions, answering only 5 out of 12, and most assuredly not answering the most interesting and revealing of them. Sample: “This is a question I ask all of my chef and foodie friends: What would be your last supper?” And, “Considering your life and career up to this point, what would you most like to be remembered for?” “What is your daughter’s favorite birthday cake? What is your favorite cake?” Some answers I received: The chocolate cake on the cover was chosen because “it’s beautiful and delicious and anyone can put it together ‘from scratch.’ ” Her favorite cake is lemon meringue. She dines at Nick and Toni’s and La Fondita. She supports “the local small farmers and gardeners that use fresh locally-sourced ingredients.”

    This entire process of being courted by a person (or her people) who wants your paper to give her publicity, thereby making her more money, and then being blown off numerous times got me to thinking. How hard is it nowadays to reach an ultra-famous, super-busy, accomplished person, and get him or her to answer your questions? I gave myself a challenge. As Martha chose not to answer “What is your daughter’s favorite birthday cake?” and this made me very sad, I thought I would put that simple question out into the atmosphere.

    A friend of a friend of a friend knows Jeff Bezos’s mother, Jackie. We wrote her an e-mail asking what Jeff’s favorite cake is. Keep in mind, these people have no reason to reply, they are not promoting a cake book or asking our newspaper to interview and write about the author. F.Y.I., Jeff Bezos is the founder and C.E.O. of Amazon.com, just bought The Washington Post, and is on the Bloomberg Billionaire Index as one of the world’s wealthiest people. His mom wrote back within 12 hours. “I don’t know what Jeff’s favorite cake is actually. Think it has changed since he was little. He had four kids so birthday cake is a frequent offering. You could ask Jeff [his actual, personal e-mail address inserted here] or I could forward for you.” Within 24 hours we got an answer from Mr. Bezos himself: “Zebra cake. It also might be the easiest cake in the world.”

    Thank you, Mr. Bezos, for being human and accessible and taking the time to answer a simple personal question. Thank you, Martha Stewart Living Omnimedia employees for doing your best.

Click for recipes

News for Foodies: 10.24.13

News for Foodies: 10.24.13

Local Food News
By
Joanne Pilgrim

Highway Diner and Bar

    The Highway Diner and Bar in Wainscott, a year-round, locally-owned bar and restaurant, is gearing up for the fall and winter season with a new cocktail menu, which includes a spiced pumpkin vodka martini, and lower prices on wines by the glass.

    Peter Thomas is the new chef at Highway, and is adding new menu items such as steak frites, pastrami and gyro sandwiches, a variety of pasta dishes, seasonal soups, chili, and local seafood entrees. Every weekday night, the restaurant is offering a special $20 entrée. Mr. Thomas, a well-known chef on the East End, worked most recently at Salt on Shelter Island.

Smokin’ Wolf

    Smokin’ Wolf, a barbecue place on Pantigo Road in East Hampton, now has a place for patrons to sit indoors. With its recently received beer license, patrons may now relax and enjoy a brew with their barbecue.

Wednesday Wine Night

    At Fresh in Bridgehampton, Wednesday is wine night. All bottles of wine priced at under $100 will be offered at a 50-percent discount.

Citta’s Specials

    Weeknight specials at Cittanuova in East Hampton are as follows: on Tuesday, a choice of pizzas, along with a draft beer and dessert, is $15, on Wednesday, a New York strip steak is the special, served the diner’s choice of one of three ways, for $19, and a three-pasta sampler for $15 on Thursday nights. On Monday, during Monday night football on TV, there are complimentary wings and $4 draft beers at the bar. During a 4:30 to 5:30 p.m. daily happy hour, Cittanuova offers quartinos of pinot grigio or Chianti for $5, well drinks for $6, draft beers for $4, and small appetizers at the bar for $5.

Round Swamp Season

    Round Swamp Farm in East Hampton will close its farm stand earlier than normal this year, on Nov. 4. Those who traditionally visit the stand for soups, prepared foods, baked goods, and uncooked frozen pies for holiday dinners, have been advised to stock up early. The stand is open from 8 a.m. to 6 p.m. on Thursday through Saturday, and from 8 a.m. to 2 p.m. on Sunday.

Winemakers’ Sundays

    Those who like wine, and a weekend jaunt to the North Fork, may want to visit Noah’s in Greenport for one of its Winemakers’ Sundays. This weekend, at 6 p.m., a five-course menu will be served along with wines from the Kontokosta Winery. The menu includes an endive radicchio salad, ravioli made with Catapano goat cheese and artichokes, pan-roasted local blackfish with butternut squash puree, and braised kale with smoked paprika oil, a grilled Tuscan-braised pork tenderloin, and spiced pumpkin cake. The cost of the dinner and wine is $75 per person, plus tax and gratuity. Reservations have been recommended. 

    A la carte service will also be available at the restaurant on Sunday.

 

Seasons by the Sea: Spooky Halloween Snacks

Seasons by the Sea: Spooky Halloween Snacks

Candy apples and caramel apples are great traditional treats for Halloween.
Candy apples and caramel apples are great traditional treats for Halloween.
Popcorn balls, and candy and caramel apples are some other favorites that nobody seems to make from scratch anymore
By
Laura Donnelly

    I love Halloween. I love being scared, love haunted houses, love costumes, and love candy corn. But nowadays it seems like zombies and vampires are so popular that we are inundated with the undead, bloodsucking creatures all year round. Turn on the TV to watch something blandly amusing and ads for “The Walking Dead” or “American Horror Story” will scare the bejesus out of you. Change the channel and there’s Ted Cruz. Eeeek!

    When I was little, my brothers and I would traipse around our neighborhood with paper bags for candy and little cardboard boxes for pennies for Unicef. Our parents would follow at a discreet distance. A few neighbors made the mistake of offering apples or some homemade unwrapped treat that our mother would promptly dispose of. Razor blades! Poison! Urban legends! Once home, we would lay out our loot and swap and trade with all the seriousness of Tony Soprano divvying up crime territories with his cronies at Satriale’s. Sherman and I would finish our candy within days. John’s would last for months and he would torture us as he revealed some new Atomic Fireball or Milky Way in mid-February.

    Costumes were also simpler, and most often homemade. Got an old sheet? Presto, you’re Casper the Friendly Ghost. Got charcoal? Smudge your face and you’re a hobo. Nowadays, according to the National Retail Federation, we spend approximately $75 dollars on costumes, decor, and candy. According to the N.R.F., nearly 44 percent of Americans will wear a costume this Halloween, 13.8 percent will also dress up their pets, nearly 31 percent will celebrate at a party, 44 percent will carve a pumpkin, 20 percent will visit a haunted house, 32 percent will take their kids trick or treating, and 48 percent will decorate their yard and/or house.

    When my son was little and sweet and innocent he was Winnie the Pooh and one of the Ninja Turtles. As a teen he morphed into gory zombie creatures. Now he seems content with the irony of just being Cameron from “Ferris Bueller’s Day Off” or Kim Jong-Un. Comical and frightening.

    When it comes to food for Halloween, you can work wonders with food coloring, Jello, squid ink, slimy noodles, lychee nuts, and so on. After you carve your pumpkin, save the seeds and roast them with a little olive oil and salt. If you want to make pumpkin soup, buy the cheese or sugar pumpkins, which are pale tan and squat. They have the best flavor and are less watery than the bright orange ones. It’s also fun to hollow out the tiny pumpkins and put dips in them.

    Popcorn balls, and candy and caramel apples are some other favorites that nobody seems to make from scratch anymore. Super fresh, crisp apples are key for making these. The Milk Pail in Water Mill is a good source for pumpkins, gourds, apples, cider, and cider doughnuts for Halloween. If you want to get really creative, buy some dry ice from Berkoski’s to create a spooky, smoky vapor rising up from your bar or punch bowls. Freeze fake bugs in your ice cubes, just be careful when the cubes melt!

    There are plenty of Halloween activities coming up — haunted house tours, haunted graveyard tours, and my favorites, the ragamuffin parades in East Hampton and Sag Harbor Villages.

    Halloween is the only “holiday” or occasion that allows us to indulge our fantasies, explore our fears, and gorge on candy. Whether you want to be a fairy princess, ghoul, vampire, silly animal, or heaven forbid, this year’s number one character, Miley Cyrus, be safe, enjoy the treats, please no tricks, and have fun trying some of these recipes.

Click for recipes

News for Foodies: 10.17.13

News for Foodies: 10.17.13

Local Food News
By
Joanne Pilgrim

Paella Dinner

    A cooking class centered on making a paella dinner, to be offered by Bridgehampton’s Loaves and Fishes Cookshop at the Bridgehampton Inn on Saturday, will include instructions for making both seafood and chicken and sausage paella. For dessert, a milk chocolate flan with a pistachio sable sauce will be prepared. The class takes place from 6 to 9 p.m. and costs $165.

The Merliance

    East End wineries that produce merlot have teamed up to create Merliance, a cooperative merlot blend. With the newest addition, Lieb Cellars of Cut­chogue, the producers number seven, including Clovis Point, McCall Wines, Raphael, Sherwood House Vineyards, T’Jara Vineyards, and Wolffer Estate Vineyard. Two barrels of Lieb Cellars’ merlot will be included in the 2012 vintage of Merliance.

    Lieb was recently acquired by Southport Lane, a private equity firm, and is under the business leadership of Peter Pace, and technical direction of Russell Hearn, an East End winemaker and founding member of Merliance. The Merliance group seeks to advance research and quality initiatives as well as the perception of merlot and merlot blends as Long Island’s “signature wines.”

Fresh Family Night

    A family night menu at Fresh restaurant in Bridgehampton includes starters such as organic sweet corn chowder, Greek salad, and kale chips, followed by a choice of entrees including pan-seared local skate or porgy and grass-fed beef hamburgers. Service begins daily at 5 p.m.

Winemakers’ Sundays

    At Noah’s in Greenport, a five-course tasting dinner on Sunday at 6 p.m. will feature pairings of wines from Sparkling Pointe. On the menu will be a local white root vegetable soup, Catapano goat cheese salad, Maine lobster and local potato ravioli, pepper-crusted filet mignon, and a crème brulee duo for dessert. The cost is $76 per person plus tax and gratuity. Reservations have been strongly recommended.

East End Eats: The Tavern, An Insider’s Favorite

East End Eats: The Tavern, An Insider’s Favorite

The basement tavern of the 1770 House in East Hampton is an intimate inner sanctum to some and a creepy windowless basement to others. Either way, it is appropriate for the season and has a great menu supported by the full upstairs dining choices.
The basement tavern of the 1770 House in East Hampton is an intimate inner sanctum to some and a creepy windowless basement to others. Either way, it is appropriate for the season and has a great menu supported by the full upstairs dining choices.
Morgan McGivern
The 1770 House is a beautifully restored inn with pretty rooms, a charming garden in back, a little cottage, and basically two restaurants
By
Laura Donnelly

1770 House Tavern

143 Main Street

East Hampton

324-1770

Dinner nightly

    It’s Columbus Day weekend and the Hamptons International Film Festival is on the South Fork so I know all of you ladies and gentlemen and black-clad cinephiles want to know where to eat. With movies being shown in six locations from Southampton to Montauk your dining options are plentiful. However, if you check the festival’s Web site looking for places to eat, you may be steered in an out-of-date direction. Some of the recommendations are Rugosa, oops, closed, and now the excellent Highway Diner, Spring Close, closed, Copa, gone, Almond, moved, Turtle Crossing, defunct. The only restaurants in Sag Harbor mentioned are the Corner Bar and Il Cappuccino. Really?

    This is not a dining guide for this upcoming weekend. (If you want to know where to eat, within any price range, in any of the villages showing movies this weekend, ask a local. In East Hampton, Rowdy Hall, Sam’s, Cittanuova, and Nick and Toni’s are favorites.) This is a review of one of my favorite fall and winter spots, the Tavern downstairs at the 1770 House.

    The 1770 House is a beautifully restored inn with pretty rooms, a charming garden in back, a little cottage, and basically two restaurants. The upstairs one is comfortable but more formal. Take the tiny, winding stairs down to the tavern and you have two seating options. Turn right and you are in the small bar area with a few tables, a fireplace, and the ubiquitous flat-screen TV. Turn left and you are in another small cozy dining room, rather like an underground pub. People who dine here have strong opinions. Some don’t like the dimly lit atmosphere and the feeling of being underground in close quarters. I adore it. The gray-green wooden banquettes wrap around the small room and have plush paisley cushions. Lighting is provided by dim sconces and votive candles. The Tavern has its own, less formal menu, but you can also order anything from the grander upstairs menu.

    The meal begins with some nice warm sourdough rolls with olive oil for dipping. You used to get a choice of warm cheesy brioche and black olive twists as well, which were deliciously rich and threatened to spoil your appetite. Perhaps they are saving pennies now.

    We began our meal with oysters on the half shell, beet salad, foie gras, and corn and potato chowder. The oysters (Hog’s Neck Bay, North Fork), received raves from everyone but the best part was the super tangy frozen cucumber mignonette, crunchy like a granita. The beet salad was also excellent. The wedges of Balsam Farm beets were tossed with julienned endive, toasted hazelnuts and dabs of salty blue cheese. The dressing was citrusy and light and may have had a drop or two of additional nut oil. The slight bitterness of the endive contrasted nicely with the sweet beets.

    The foie gras (always on the menu at 1770 and always good) was seared and served with local peach compote and a warm brioche emulsion. I don’t know what a warm brioche emulsion is but my teenage gourmand guest, Lara, who ordered it wished she had gotten some toasts alongside. The local corn and potato chowder was very good, thick and rich and corny.

    For entrees we ordered the Tavern burger, the Tavern meatloaf, salmon, and roasted chicken. The burger at 1770 is justifiably famous. It is big, served on a brioche bun, juicy from the right degree of fat content, and served with crispy fries. A tray of condiments arrives before you have to ask for them. The Tavern meatloaf is another signature dish you can always find on the menu. The presentation is new; the meatloaf is served as one large oval slice on a bed of mashed potatoes, with roast garlic gravy all around, and a mild, roasted garlic clove adorning the top. Barely sauteed spinach tries to find room on the generous platter. This is a good deal for $22!

    The salmon was also a generous portion, served with a tart tomatillo salsa, kabocha squash, duck confit, and smoked apple. It was cooked medium and was perfectly seasoned. The roasted chicken was also excellent. There is nothing better than a half chicken that has been boned for you, has a crunchy crust, and remains moist inside. And it tastes “chickeny” as Julia Child used to say. The spiced sweet potato puree and sesame baby bok choy served alongside were also delicious.

    The service on the night of our visit was excellent. Our waitress, Tina, knew her wines and was perfectly charming. There are always several people on hand, refilling your water glasses and making sure each guest is served at exactly the same time, smooth and unobtrusive. Prices at 1770 are $12 to $24 for appetizers, $20 to $42 for entrees, with sides for $9, desserts $10 to $12.

    We were too stuffed for dessert but this was a belated birthday occasion so we got a slice of ricotta cheesecake and a little tres leches cake with candles in them for the table. The ricotta cheesecake was fluffy and fresh, served with a crunchy hazelnut crust, sitting on a crosshatch pattern of blueberry compote and caramel sauce with a mound of fresh blueberries on the side. The tres leches cake was moist, sweet, and rich, served with a scoop of refreshing coconut sorbet.

    The Tavern menu at the 1770 House seems shorter, more streamlined than it used to be, but this is okay since, as mentioned before, you can order from the upstairs menu, as well. The executive chef, Kevin Penner, put the 1770 House on the map when it re-opened over 10 years ago. It is now in the professional and capable hands of another former Della Femina chef, Michael Rozzi. The restaurant is on the expensive side but it must be noted, there are always good values on the menu and the prix fixe menus through the winter are the best out here.

    Whether you want a grand filet mignon with Bordelaise emulsion or a simple wild mushroom pizza, 1770 House will have a variety of choices for you, offered in a cozy, professional, and welcoming atmosphere.

 

News for Foodies: 10.10.13

News for Foodies: 10.10.13

Local Food News
By
Joanne Pilgrim

    Reservations are being taken for a Nov. 1 wine dinner called France Uncorked, featuring French wines and five courses at the Living Room restaurant in East Hampton, at c/o the Maidstone inn.

    Co-sponsored by Park Place Wines and Liquors, the dinner will begin at 7:30 p.m. and costs $145 per person. The menu will include oysters four ways and sea scallop carpaccio followed by pulled, slow-baked pheasant with sautéed chanterelles on toasted brioche with frisee salad and caramelized onions. After that, tournedos Rossini, a French steak dish with foie gras, will be served, followed by a dessert of chocolate ganache with raspberry compote. A different wine will be served with each course.

Artists, Writers at Almond

    Almond restaurant in Bridgehampton is reintroducing its artists and writers nights, when diners may eat a prix fixe served family-style and hear from a guest of the night. On Wednesday, the speaker will be Janet Goleas, a freelance art curator who recently created “The Moby Project,” a multi-disciplinary exhibit centered on the themes in “Moby-Dick.” The evening begins at 7 p.m. and will cost $40 in advance, or $45 at the door. The fee includes three courses, a glass of local wine or craft beer, and tax and gratuity.

Dinner Tonight

    Diners at four local restaurants tonight will help to support the Amagansett Food Institute, which will receive 20 percent of the evening’s proceeds from Almond, La Fondita, Fresh, and Meeting House. The institute, a fledgling organization formed to support East End farmers and food producers, has 20 members, including Amber Waves Farm, Anke’s Fit Bakery, Gula Gula Empanadas, Open Minded Organics, Fat Ass Fudge, and Bhumi Farm.

Harvest Cooking

    A cooking class at the Bridgehampton Inn on Saturday, sponsored by the Loaves and Fishes Cookshop in Bridgehampton, will center on cooking with pears and pumpkins. Carolyn Giacalone will teach students how to make pumpkin gnocchi, roasted stuffed hens with pear and walnut stuffing, roasted Brussels sprouts with pancetta, and caramel­ized pear tart with pumpkin ice cream. The class will take place from 6 to 9 p.m. and cost $165.

Pie Class

    Leslie Dumont at Proud to Be Flakey Pie School will give a class on making apple pies and tarts on Oct. 20 from noon to 3:30 p.m. The $75 cost includes refreshments during the session and a pie crust to take home. Registration is through the school’s Web site.

Seasons by the Sea: A Toast to the Happy Couple

Seasons by the Sea: A Toast to the Happy Couple

Oysters such as the Montauk Pearl, Hama Hama, Olympia, and Belon served at Bell and Anchor in Noyac pair well with a variety of local and international white wines.
Oysters such as the Montauk Pearl, Hama Hama, Olympia, and Belon served at Bell and Anchor in Noyac pair well with a variety of local and international white wines.
Jennifer Landes
After a recent toot to the North Fork, we stopped by Bell and Anchor for some oyster research
By
Laura Donnelly

    I know very little about food and wine pairing but am an eager student. I appreciate meals moistened with wine chosen by a friend in the know. But I also agree with Richard Olney’s philosophy that “it is a mistake to freeze such a variable and seductive landscape with rigid rules.”

    Without a doubt the wines of different regions of France go with the foods grown, harvested, and caught in that region. An example would be the aged goat cheese crottin de Chavignol paired with Sancerre, or oysters with muscadet. The same is true of Long Island wines. Once you try a Montauk Pearl oyster with a sip of Paumanok’s un-oaked chardonnay, you would agree. Some young Catapano goat cheese with a sauvignon blanc from the the new Kontakosta Winery in Greenport is light and uncomplicated.

    After a recent toot to the North Fork, we stopped by Bell and Anchor for some oyster research. As it was a quiet Sunday, our waiter, Michael, delighted in preparing a flight of oysters, East Coast vs. West Coast, matched with several wines. We had Montauk Pearl, Hama Hama, Olympia, and Belon oysters with Lieb’s pinot blanc, Paumanok chardonnay, Livon pinot grigio, and a Sancerre blend. The Montauk Pearls were our favorite, especially with the un-oaked chardonnay. The Olympias were quite briny but they “played nice” with the Sancerre. The Belons were almost coppery tasting and creamy, excellent with the pinot blanc.

    The fun really began when the chef Sam McCleland stopped by our table to chat. He admitted that he enjoys rosé all year round (my kinda guy!) and had just enjoyed some local blackfish with Channing Daughters rosé. Out from the kitchen came a special of that evening, oysters Rockefeller. This was followed by another order . . . and then another. We chatted about the foods he is looking forward to cooking this fall, duck and venison and all manner of braised meats, porchetta, and so on. He was especially excited about the upcoming scallop season.

    “Thirty seconds! That’s all the cooking they need!” Through the miracle of technology, his partner in Bell and Anchor, David Loewenberg, got wind of our research and sent us a message about his favorite oyster pairings. “I love our great local oysters, Montauk Pearls, Naked Cowboys, and Widow’s Hole with a classic sauvignon blanc. Channing Daughters 2012 Mudd sauvignon blanc has just the right acidity to balance the salinity of these great shellfish. Then again, we love pink with everything!”

    As I said before, I am really not terribly knowledgeable about food and wine pairings. My cooking tends to be more savory or spicy than rich and creamy. I am more inclined to use garlic, fresh herbs, lemon juice, and vinegars than I am cream and butter. Indian, Italian, and Thai foods are my favorites, so I know enough to not present a rich Montrachet with a fiery pad thai. My everyday go-to wines are sauvignon blanc or Sancerre for whites, and a light pinot noir for red. And, like my aforementioned foodie friends, rosé all year round.

    I have long been a firm believer in the quality of Long Island wines. They tend to be on the expensive side, but I attribute this to real estate value. Lately, the more knowledgeable oenophiles and wine experts like Jay McInerney are giving the North and South Fork wines some attention and praise.

    As we come into the cooler fall months, do a little experimentation of your own. Get some local cauliflower and apples and make a puree to go with braised local duck or duck breast glazed with beach plum jelly. Talk to your favorite wine merchant about what to drink with it. Jacques Franey of Domaine Franey, Michael Cinque of Amagansett Wines and Spirits, and Rodney at Wines by Morrell are all happy to help with wine and food pairings. They are well-informed and always respectful of your budget.

    Wine knowledge is useful and research is fun, but the whole raison d’etre of the meal is the company. Whether you’re having a roast Iacono Farm chicken with a simple green salad and Mecox Bay Dairy cheeses or a lobster feast with end of season corn succotash, experiment with local wines, relax, and have fun with your family and friends.

Click for recipes