Skip to main content

Kitchen or No Kitchen?

Kitchen or No Kitchen?

By
Bridget LeRoy

    A Main Street apartment and a possible pergola on Lily Pond Lane were at the forefront of discussion during October’s East Hampton Village Zoning Board of Appeals meetings.

    Alice Cooley, an attorney from MacLachlan and Eagan in East Hampton, was there to represent Steven and Carolyn Kotler of 123 Lily Pond Lane, who requested a 17-foot area variance for a pergola. It would be the same size as an existing pergola, but would have a double wall and be much taller, 12 feet high.

    “This is the only location where the pergola can provide noise abatement,” said Ms. Cooley, who added that the structure would have a solid wall at the back, and a lattice with plastic leaves woven throughout to reduce the noise from the neighbors’ pool.

    Andrew Goldstein, chairman of the zoning board, had “a problem with the height.”

    “Did you have a sound engineer design this?” he asked. The answer was no. “Then how do you know it’s going to work?” he said.

    “The problem I have is typically when we’re asked to approve some

thing for noise abatement, there’s expert testimony to comment on the efficacy of the plan,” Mr. Goldstein said. “And I’m not inclined to grant this unless I hear from an expert.”

    Lys Marigold, a board member, was concerned about the precedent it might set.

    “We’re being asked to approve this because, ‘What the hell, it’s just another wall,’ ” Mr. Goldstein said. “We won’t do that.” The hearing was adjourned until Dec. 9.

    The owners of 23 Main Street L.L.C. were represented by Brian Matthews, also of Maclachlan and Eagan, in seeking a variance on a required permit for parking. The three-story building has apartments upstairs, with a kitchen on the first floor. The application, to demolish the kitchen and expand the retail space from 604 square feet to 964 square feet, had been denied by the building inspector.

    “No permits or [certificates of occupancy] were ever issued for this property,” said Mr. Matthews. “And there’s no mention of a first-floor kitchen in any previous document.” He argued that since the kitchen was never cited in a document, the building must have been converted from retail to residential space illegally.

    However, John L. McGuirk III, a board member, recalled visiting the occupants in the mid-1970s, prior to village building codes. “The kitchen was there,” he said.

    “The building inspector acted reasonably when he denied your permit,” Mr. Goldstein said. “You haven’t submitted sufficient evidence. You’re asking us to believe that at some point this was converted into a kitchen on the first floor, when it may be the way it always was.”

    The expansion would require the occupants to provide seven parking spaces instead of the six it has now.

    “It’s so minimal it would not impact or exacerbate the parking issues in the village,” Mr. Matthews said, adding that many shoppers are visiting more than one store when they park.

    Mr. Goldstein disagreed, citing the gridlock that occurs in the summer in the Reutershan parking lot, where the machines at the entrances have dispensed 750,000 tickets to allow parking in the past year.

    “That’s a lot of cars,” he pointed out. “While one spot is not a lot, if it’s too tight, it’s too tight.”

    The hearing was left open until Dec.

Logbook Goes To Southold

Logbook Goes To Southold

By
Russell Drumm

    A ledger has recently come to light, a kind of logbook that chronicled the day-to-day activities at the Ditch Plain, Montauk, lifesaving station during the five-year period from 1873 to 1878. Trouble is, you will have to go to Southold to see it.

    The Southold Historical Society purchased the ledger for its Horton Point Lighthouse Museum after it was offered for sale by a private collector.

    “We were contacted by a dealer who acquired it. He contacted a number of institutions. It was in excellent condition. We have collections related to the U.S. Life Saving Service,” said Geoffrey Fleming, director of the Horton Light museum.

     The Life Saving Service operated stations all along the coast. It was one of the Coast Guard’s precursor agencies. 

    Mr. Fleming said his museum bought the log last summer at a cost “in the low thousands,” along with a number of photographs of East End lifesaving stations. He said the book details a number of rescues, maintenance information, and shipwrecks, of which the most tragic was surely the wreck of the Circassian off Bridgehampton. On Jan 1, The New York Times reported that “the search for the bodies of the unfortunate men of the ship Circassian was rewarded yesterday afternoon by the discovery of three corpses which were thrown up on the shore about four miles [west] of Montauk Point. The wind did not abate until nightfall, yet it was not so keen as to drive off the patrolling men of the Life Saving Service.”

    The lifesaving station was certainly the Ditch Plain Station. The bodies were those of three crewman, all of whom were Shinnecock Indians. The wreck itself occurred on the stormy night of Dec. 11.

    Mr. Fleming said that yes, he had been contacted after the sale by a representative of the Montauk Lighthouse Museum. Tricia Wood, the Montauk museum’s site manager, said Tuesday that while the Horton Light museum was not interested in selling the book, it would consider lending it to Montauk sometime in the future.

    More information about the ledger can be found on the Southold Historical Society’s Web site, southoldhistoricalsociety.org.

Village Honors Vets, Roasts Bruce Siska

Village Honors Vets, Roasts Bruce Siska

The Maidstone Gun Club held its annual “turkey shoot” Sunday at its Daniel’s Hole Road facility. Prizes for good scores included certificates for turkeys and chickens. The Maidstone Gun Club held its annual “turkey shoot” Sunday at its Daniel’s Hole Road facility. Prizes for good scores included certificates for turkeys and chickens.
Morgan McGivern
By
Bridget LeRoy

    The future of the Thomas Moran House, the Long Island Power Authority’s answer to Tropical Storm Irene, and plaques and proclamations were on the agenda at Friday’s East Hampton Village Board meeting.

    Marti Mayo, the executive director of the Thomas Moran Trust, gave an update on the house at 229 Main Street. It is deteriorating, she said, with some sections on the verge of collapse.

    The house, built in 1884 as the home of the artists Thomas Moran and his wife, Mary Nimmo Moran, was designated a National Historic Landmark very early on, in 1965, when the landmark program was only two years old. “Even the Statue of Liberty wasn’t designated until 1992,” Ms. Mayo said.

    The house was privately owned until 2004, when Elizabeth “Boots” Lamb died. A trust was formed in 2007 to bring the property back to its 1916 appearance, which the trust deems the apex of its heyday.

    The cost of the renovation, which includes structural work, landscaping,  ground and water studies, and experts to match paints, textiles, and more, will be in the $8 million range. The trust has raised almost half that amount, $3.5 million.

    “We’re anxious to be a good neighbor,” said Ms. Mayo. “And we take our responsibilities seriously. This will be a wonderful monument to this artist,” whose famous paintings of the Western landscape led directly to the creation of Yellowstone National Park.

    Having to negotiate the hurdles required at state and federal levels has  caused a time issue for the trust. Ms. Mayo, who has been on the job since April, was “hopeful, no promises” that renovations would begin within the next several months, but wanted to know whether the board might give it another year to get fully under way.

    “I think we’d be inclined to look favorably on it,” Mayor Paul F. Rickenbach said. “But we would have to draw a line in the sand after that.”

    Bruce Siska, the newest member of the board, got a roasting from Hugh King, who graduated from East Hampton High School with Mr. Siska in 1959. Mr. King brought his high school yearbook and searched through it, chuckling, for mention of Mr. Siska in the popularity polls. There was none. “He did marry Mary Talmage, who was voted ‘most sincere,’ ” Mr. King said. When the board asked which popularity contest Mr. King had won, he acknowledged, “best all-around.”

    Steven Tricario, a district manager for the Long Island Power Authority on eastern Long Island, introduced himself to the board as its government liaison. In the aftermath of Tropical Storm Irene, the village had sent a strongly worded letter to LIPA chastising it for a breakdown in communications.

    “I don’t think it was the [fault of] the workers who came out here during Irene,” said the mayor. “They did a yeoman’s job. It was a problem of communication.”

    Mr. Tricario said that “moving forward, our goal is to provide safe and reliable service.”

    The mayor issued a proclamation to honor veterans during Veterans Appreciation Week, from Nov. 5 through Nov. 11.

    There to accept the plaque was August Bouker, who thanked everyone for their continued support of veterans. The Veterans Day parade, sponsored by V.F.W. Post 550 and American Legion Post 419, will start in front of London Jewelers at 10 a.m. on Nov. 11.

Chamber of Commerce Fall Festival Weekend

Chamber of Commerce Fall Festival Weekend

By
Janis Hewitt

    The Montauk Chamber of Commerce will be host its 30th fall festival on Saturday and Sunday, and, appropriately, 30 restaurants have promised to donate New England and Manhattan clam chowders for the popular chowder tasting contest on Saturday.

    The festival runs from 11 a.m. to 5 p.m. on Saturday and from noon to 5 on Sunday, but be warned: Lines for the chowder tasting start forming early on Saturday. The winners in both categories, who will be chosen by the people and food critics from local newspapers, will be announced at 3 p.m. on Saturday.

    On both days, there will also be a 30-horse carousel, inflatable rides, crab races, pumpkin decorating, face painting, live music, oysters and clams on the half shell, and other October-fest style food. There will be street games, a farmers market, plant sales, and wine and beer tastings. This year, the chamber has also added a new attraction, the wheel of chance.

    On Sunday the folks from the Montauk Playhouse Community Center will join the fun under a tent from noon to 3 p.m., where there will be live music, a silent auction with prizes that range from gift certificates from local restaurants, stores, and motels to handbags, paintings, technical gadgets, gift baskets, and more. A separate silent auction will feature sports and entertainment memorabilia. Popcorn, cotton candy, and baked goods will be available for purchase.

    On Sunday, the chamber will pull the winning tickets in its Cash Catch raffle, with prizes expected to total  $29,000, depending on how many tickets are sold. The tickets cost $50 apiece and will be sold right up to the drawing.

    The festival is a fund-raiser for the Montauk Food Pantry, the chamber’s Frank A. Cappozola Scholarship award, the annual Montauk fireworks display, and other events that the chamber hosts.

    Volunteers are still needed. Those interested can contact Pat Shea at the chamber office.

New War on Parade Drunks

New War on Parade Drunks

By
Janis Hewitt

Representatives from the Montauk Friends of Erin, the Montauk Chamber of Commerce, the East Hampton Town Police Department, and the Metropolitan Transportation Authority will gather next week at Gurney’s Inn to discuss how to discourage drunken, under-age people from attending the annual St. Patrick’s Day parade in the hamlet.

Chamber officials drew up the petitions that have been posted in the chamber and at local businesses asking the transportation authority not to send trains to Montauk on March 12, the day of next year’s parade.

“In the past few years, those trains have brought thousands of youths, many inebriated and under age, and has resulted in taking away the fun, family tradition that had been enjoyed for many years,” the petition says.

Residents have embraced the petition, Joe Bloecker, the president of the Friends of Erin, said. He explained that the plan is to have the petitions at the meeting so that the representatives of the M.T.A. can see just how many people in Montauk don’t like what happens every year at the parade.

“It’ll give us a leg to stand on,” Mr. Bloecker said. “The problems are coming off the trains. We don’t want that and we don’t want them to send any trains. They’re not doing us any favors.”

If the M.T.A. doesn’t cooperate, the Friends of Erin are considering starting the parade at 10 a.m. to circumvent the revelers, most of whom, according to Mr. Bloecker, will have attended parades in other areas on the previous day and will be too hung over to jump a train that early in the morning. But the idea has not been “set in stone,” he said, and the group is happy to negotiate.

Chamber members don’t want to see the time changed, as that will deter families from driving out for the festivities, which have attracted crowds of up to 40,000 people in the past. “People up west would have to leave at 5 a.m. to get out that early,” said Laraine Creegan, the chamber’s executive director. “We’re really not taking a stand. We love the parade. We’re just concerned about the earlier timing.”

Sal Arena, an M.T.A. spokesman, said yesterday that the agency would discuss the parade with Ms. Creegan at next week’s meeting.

Apparently last year’s parade was one of the worst. Mr. Bloecker said that 95 percent of the arrests were related to under-age drinkers trying to get into bars and the fights that ensued. He said the bars all had good security, but that “the reason the fights take place outside the bars is because they won’t let them in. And then it makes them look bad” when the revelers hang around.

Following last year’s parade the Friends of Erin started brainstorming on how to tame the rowdy crowds and return the parade to the families. They came up with the earlier start time but kept it a secret until recently, Mr. Bloecker said. “Enough is enough.”

Several years ago, security was tightened, with a wider range of police officers — from the town, the M.T.A., the state park police, and the highway patrol. They were posted at the train station with drug-and-alcohol-sniffing dogs and confiscated containers of alcohol as they were carried off the train.

It helped for a year or two, but the trouble escalated at last year’s event when, to avoid the police and a search of their backpacks, a number of paradegoers jumped from the train, sneaked under the platform, and exited on Industrial Road, south of the station, Mr. Bloecker said.

The Friends of Erin and the chamber of commerce are encouraging public comment to help in the final decision.

“We need to let the people in Montauk know that we don’t support these people coming out here,” Mr. Bloecker said. “If they don’t stop the train, we will change the parade start to 10 a.m.”

Nuclear Threat To Montauk?

Nuclear Threat To Montauk?

By
Janis Hewitt

    The Concerned Citizens of Montauk will meet for its annual meeting on Saturday at 4 p.m. at the Montauk Fire Department. After a brief business meeting, the folks will sit back for the general meeting, which will include a lecture titled, “Twenty Miles to Millstone: Is Nuclear Power a Threat to Montauk?”

    Appearing on a panel of experts will be Karl Grossman, a journalist who has written extensively on nuclear power, and Suffolk County Legislator Jay Schneiderman, a Montauk resident.

    The 40-year-old Millstone nuclear facility in Waterford, Conn., is the same distance from Montauk as Montauk is from the Bridgehampton Commons, C.C.O.M. pointed out in a press release, meaning that a problem there could pose a danger to communities across the Sound.

    Panelists will discuss the prospect of evacuating Long Island and the need to reassess reliance on nuclear power. The danger of nuclear power was brought to the fore after a major earthquake and devastating tsunami in Japan earlier this year damaged nuclear reactors at the Fukushima, Daiichi, power plant, leading to a major nuclear crisis.

    Since then, C.C.O.M. said, other major economies have moved aggressively away from nuclear power, while officials in the United States limited their response to a review of the 104 plants across the country. Earlier this month, federal inspectors cited Millstone for operating at capacities far beyond those permitted.

    The panelists will discuss the fact that despite these findings there has been no reconsideration of recent license extensions permitting the facility’s two reactors to operate for an additional 20 years, prolonging the plant’s intended 40-year life span.   

Never Too Early for Green

Never Too Early for Green

By
Janis Hewitt

    In honor of the group’s 50th year, the Montauk Friends of Erin will kick off the season of the green a bit early with a Halfway to St. Patrick’s Day party on Saturday at 3 p.m.

    But before that, at noon, the friends will unveil a new monument on the downtown green dedicated to the 50 grand marshals who have led the St. Patrick’s Day parade that traditionally wakes up the sleepy hamlet after a long winter and draws thousands of people. The Amityville Highland Pipe Band will perform, and a Coast Guard color guard will lead the ceremony.

    The monument will include the name of the parade’s 2012 grand marshal, which usually isn’t announced until late January. “It’s been hard to keep it a secret since we decided early in the summer,” said Joe Bloecker, the president of the friends. “I thought a monument would be a nice gesture to the grand marshals and their families, most of whom still live in Montauk,” he said.

    Mr. Bloecker came up with the idea for a memorial and the rest of the friends were enthusiastic about it, he said. On Tuesday morning, the East Hampton Town Board approved the monument, which has been placed just to the east of the steps to the gazebo. Construction began later that day. The materials and labor were donated by Tom and Kathy Ciccariello of the Seven Sons landscaping company.

    The final piece engraved with this year’s grand marshal’s name will not be installed until just before the unveiling ceremony. “We can’t let anyone know who it is before Saturday,” Mr. Bloecker said. Rumors have been spreading for the last week.

    The party afterward will run till 7 p.m. at the Old Harbor House. The $50 tickets include an open bar, a barbecue, and live music and dancing. Tickets can be bought in advance at Becker’s Home Center or at the Montauk Chamber of Commerce.

Lyme Disease Documentary

Lyme Disease Documentary

    “Under Our Skin,” a much-anticipated documentary film about Lyme disease, will be shown tomorrow night at 7 at LTV Studio 3 Cinema in Wainscott. Directed by Andy Abrahams, the film investigates this often misdiagnosed malady, which is all too well known on the East End, drawing disconcerting conclusions about the failings of the health care industry.

 According to the Centers for Disease Control, Lyme disease cases have increased by a staggering 94 percent since 2004, almost doubling between then and 2009, when the last numbers were compiled. “Under Our Skin” attempts to counter the ever-growing complications surrounding  the disease, from doctors’ diagnoses to costly battles with insurance companies and varying treatment possibilities.

 A panel discussion will follow the film, featuring Dr. Joseph Burrascano, a Lyme disease specialist who lives in East Hampton, and Stacey Sobel, the executive director of the Turn the Corner Foundation, which is dedicated to Lyme education and research.

Tomorrow night’s event is a pre-screening of the Hamptons Take 2 Film Festival, which is scheduled for Nov. 18 through Nov. 20. Tickets are $15, available at the door.

Ditches Plastic, Offers Paper

Ditches Plastic, Offers Paper

Christina Lescano, an employee of the Amagansett I.G.A., with some of the paper bags the store now uses exclusively.
Christina Lescano, an employee of the Amagansett I.G.A., with some of the paper bags the store now uses exclusively.
Morgan McGivern
By
Bridget LeRoy

    Those who shop at the I.G.A. in Amagansett (also known as Cirillo’s Market) can choose to put their groceries in the paper bags provided or take their own totes. Frances Cirillo, who runs the company from her offices in East Setauket, has discontinued the use of plastic shopping bags in the grocery store altogether . . . and no one even had to ask.

    “Ultimately, it’s the right thing to do,” she said by telephone on Tuesday. “It’s the direction things are going in.”

    The Amagansett supermarket, which has been in the Cirillo family since the early 1970s, made the switch about a month ago.

    East Hampton Village passed a ban on plastic grocery bags at the end of July, emulating the action taken by Southampton Village in April. The latest ban does not go into effect until the beginning of next year, but there has already been talk at board meetings that East Hampton Town may not be far behind.

    However, Ms. Cirillo said, the potentially looming townwide law was not the reason for her voluntary compliance.

    “It’s good for the environment,” she said. “It’s good for our grandchildren. It’s the way to go.”

    She said that paper bags are slightly more expensive — around 11 cents each, compared to “pennies” for plastic — but she did not sound fazed in the least about it.

    “When you know you’re doing the right thing for yourself, for your children, for the environment, it doesn’t matter as much,” she said.

    “Surprised, but positive,” is how Eric Morris of East Hampton, one of the Amagansett store’s managers, characterized the reaction of customers who have noticed the change. “We’ve had nothing but positive feedback.”

    The store’s other manager, Gustavo Renata, said that reviews on the plastic ban have been mixed. “For some people, it’s harder to change,” he said.

Thanks for Nuttin’, Irene

Thanks for Nuttin’, Irene

By
Carissa Katz

    Irene was the big weather news in August, but as tropical storms and hurricanes go, it “could have been more severe,” Richard G. Hendrickson, the United States Cooperative weather observer in Bridgehampton, wrote in his monthly report for August.

    “It stayed on its northward path and we were spared the true severity of its wind and high ocean,” he said. “Some trees are down and many, many branches are torn off trees. High tidal water, some shore erosion, but mild compared to the damage done during the path of some of our previous hurricanes.”

    Mr. Hendrickson, who has been observing and recording weather in Bridgehampton for more than seven decades, knows of what he speaks.

    Daytime temperatures last month were mainly in the 80s, according to his report. The warmest days — at 88 degrees — came on Aug. 1 and 8, but it was in the 80s on 20 other days, as well. The coolest night was on Aug. 12, when the temperature dropped to 52.

    Mr. Hendrickson recorded 9 clear days, 10 partly cloudy days, and 12 cloudy ones. Measurable rain fell on 10 days, for a total of 4.19 inches, making for an excellent crop of summer vegetables in both quality and quantity, he said. Prevailing winds were from the southwest on 13 days.

    “Let’s hope that September can be as mild and storm free as last year,” he wrote. “Our coming late-summer days should be mild and clear. Yet, in the long run, some of our heaviest rains have come in the month of September.”