Skip to main content

On the Police Logs 05.15.25

Thu, 05/15/2025 - 11:13

Amagansett

Two deer, stuck in a fence on Marine Boulevard on the morning of May 5, were freed by police without issue.

A small fire on Sunday evening, in a Montauk Highway house near the Cranberry Hole Road bridge, was determined by firefighters to have started when the homeowner turned on the air-conditioning unit for the first time this year.

East Hampton

A woman walking near Goodfriend Drive on the afternoon of May 5 reported hearing a loud boom, followed by a “bright flash.” Police found there was no power from Goodfriend Drive all the way to South Breeze Drive, and PSEG confirmed an “active outage,” with possible restoration around 4 a.m. the next day.

That same afternoon, firefighters were summoned to extinguish flames in a dryer on Grape Arbor Lane, which they did in short order.

East Hampton Village

A Newtown Lane woman called about a large tree branch hanging precariously over her lawn and sidewalk on the evening of May 6, and police called in the Highway Department to remove it.

An Uber driver waved down an officer who was patrolling Main Street early Sunday morning to say that a drunken passenger was refusing to get out of his car. The officer got the man out, and family members arrived to take him back to their hotel.

Sag Harbor

A driver was sitting in traffic right in front of the Brick Kiln Road firehouse on May 6 when his car was rear-ended by a Jeep Wrangler. When he pulled into the firehouse to check for damage, the Jeep drove off, he told police. “No substantial damage” was reported.

A caller reported a loud fire alarm going off in the vicinity of Madison Street on the evening of May 6. Police found it, still ringing, inside a trash bag, and removed the battery. Rain had likely entered it and set it off, they reported.

A woman told police on Friday afternoon that her cat was stuck in a tree and would not come down, but that she’d called an arborist friend who was on the way to help.

Springs

A driver who’d damaged two mailboxes at the corner of Fleming Street and Fort Pond Boulevard on May 7 later called both homeowners, apologized, and offered to pay for the damage. 

Wainscott

A fuel truck was reported engulfed in flames last Thursday afternoon on Daniel’s Hole Road, and its driver sustained minor scratches to his arm while jumping down to safety. East Hampton firefighters extinguished the blaze.

Driver and Passenger Booked

A driver and his passenger were both arrested by Sag Harbor Village police in the early morning hours on Sunday, one charged with drunken driving and the other with resisting arrest.

Mar 26, 2026

Jury Conviction in D.W.I. Case

An East Hampton man faces up to four years in prison after he was found guilty of felony-level driving while intoxicated on March 16.

Mar 26, 2026

Justin Timberlake Footage Will Be Released

Footage of Justin Timberlake’s adjudicated June 2024 drunken-driving arrest in Sag Harbor will soon be released in redacted form, according to court documents filed Friday by the pop star’s lawyers.

Mar 20, 2026

On the Police Logs 03.19.26

Reports of a suspicious vehicle in Montauk on Saturday night turned out to be several Patchogue residents having dinner alfresco and stargazing.

Mar 19, 2026

 

Your support for The East Hampton Star helps us deliver the news, arts, and community information you need. Whether you are an online subscriber, get the paper in the mail, delivered to your door in Manhattan, or are just passing through, every reader counts. We value you for being part of The Star family.

Your subscription to The Star does more than get you great arts, news, sports, and outdoors stories. It makes everything we do possible.