Skip to main content

Felony Assault Charges and an Eye on Montauk Hotspots

Thu, 07/22/2021 - 08:30

Colter Shelly of Whooping Hollow Road in East Hampton was charged last week with second-degree felony assault, whereby someone 10 years younger than the victim allegedly injures someone 65 or over.

East Hampton Town police reported that at home on July 11 at around 8 a.m., Mr. Shelly, 28, punched and kicked another person, whose name was withheld by police, multiple times, leaving cuts, swelling, pain, and difficulty breathing, and prompting immediate transport to Stony Brook Southampton Hospital. Mr. Shelly was held for the remainder of the day and night, and arraigned the next morning before Justice Lisa R. Rana in East Hampton Town Justice Court.

Police did a thorough sweep of Montauk party spots last week, leading to five arrests.

On July 11 at 5:15 p.m., Joseph Antonelli, 53, of New York City was charged with employing an unlicensed security guard, a misdemeanor, at the establishment he manages, Bounce Beach Montauk, after the unnamed guard was unable to produce valid identification. A second misdemeanor, for failure to correctly post an Alcohol Beverage Control sign, was filed as well. Police noted that there are three separate bars inside Bounce.

Also at Bounce, police charged two men with serving alcohol to a minor, a misdemeanor. Within 15 minutes of each other, police said, Gokhan Resber, 30, of St. George, Utah, and Mitchell Davis, 33, of Northport each sold a 12-ounce can of Corona Light beer to an undercover 20-year-old, who showed no identification.

The unnamed agent, who will be 21 next month, led police to their next arrest, at around 4:15 p.m. at the Surf Lodge. Thea Dukas, 33, of Montauk was charged this time.

All four bartenders, charged with unlawful dealing with a minor, will be arraigned in Justice Court on July 28. A fifth arrest was unfounded.

There were three arrests on town roads during the week. On Saturday afternoon, C. Tittmann, 45, of Huntington was booked for aggravated unlicensed driving. Mark Meller of Livingston, N.J., was charged with the same offense last Thursday, the day before his 62nd birthday. Finally, Henry Shamamian, 60, of Greenwich Village was ticketed for driving with a suspended registration. All three are to appear in court on July 28.

In East Hampton Village, a driver who was charged in June with lacking a license, suspended registration, and having neither inspection nor insurance, was again charged with the two misdemeanors and both violations on July 13, at 6:30 a.m.

Police stopped a blue 2002 Lexus driven by Nina Schafer, 56, of Oakview Highway, East Hampton, on Toilsome Lane near Wireless Road. The car had neither front nor rear license plates, they said. She also faces two speeding charges, one for a 44 mile-per-hour right turn onto Meadow Way in a 25 m.p.h. zone, the other for going 40 m.p.h. on Mill Hill Lane, where the limit is 20. The Lexus was impounded by Hammer Towing; she will appear in court on July 28.

Bryan Tapia Garzon, 32, of Springs was flagged down on Railroad Avenue, village police said, for texting while driving and wound up facing added charges of aggravated unlicensed driving and driving without an interlock device, required for those who have been convicted of drunken driving. Mr. Garzon appeared in court yesterday.

On the Police Logs 11.19.26

An Amagansett resident told police last week that she had just driven by a suitcase lying “in the middle of the street” near the entrance to the Reutershan parking lot.

Nov 19, 2026

Distracted by Her Phone

A Southampton woman suffered head injuries last week when she crashed her car in Montauk after reportedly looking at a weather notification on her phone.

Nov 19, 2026

On the Police Logs 11.12.26

A cygnet swan standing in the middle of Cove Hollow Road and blocking traffic on Nov. 2 proved to be uninjured and eventually flew to Georgica Pond.

Nov 12, 2026

Man Jailed in ‘Violent’ Rape

After responding to a domestic incident last week, town police charged an East Hampton man with rape and forcible compulsion.

Nov 12, 2026

 

Your support for The East Hampton Star helps us deliver the news, arts, and community information you need. Whether you are an online subscriber, get the paper in the mail, delivered to your door in Manhattan, or are just passing through, every reader counts. We value you for being part of The Star family.

Your subscription to The Star does more than get you great arts, news, sports, and outdoors stories. It makes everything we do possible.