Skip to main content

Summer Rental Was a Scam

Thu, 05/23/2019 - 07:22

When Edward Orr Sr., a driver for Road Runner Taxi in Montauk, picked up three people from Manhattan Friday morning at the Montauk train station, there was nothing unusual about the call. They were headed, on the first day of the big holiday weekend, to a summer rental on South Fulton Drive, a dirt road off Old West Lake Drive.

When they arrived at 99 South Fulton Drive, though, something was wrong: The house at that address was occupied. The photo they had seen online looked more like 93 South Fulton.

“The door to the house was open. They were saying, ‘Hello? Hello?’ ” Mr. Orr said Friday afternoon. But almost immediately, with the group already inside the house, the homeowner pulled into the driveway.

It turned out that the three, who had arranged the rental via Craigslist from an “Amanda McCall,” had been scammed. They were not the only ones who wired almost $3,000 apiece for the house, which was not for rent.

East Hampton Town police said that Joshua Meyers of New York was a victim of the same scam. He had been taken for $2,800.

Mr. Orr eventually took his three now not-so-happy visitors into downtown Montauk, where they rented rooms for the weekend, though not at the bargain price they thought they had gotten for a long-term stay on South Fulton.

“It is really too bad,” Mr. Orr said, adding, though, that by the time he left them, the three seemed to have cheered up a bit.

On the Police Logs 10.09.25

An “older gentleman” was at the bar at Rosie’s in Amagansett with a younger woman who “did not appear to be his daughter,” another patron, who was “concerned about her well-being,” reported Friday night. But she was the man’s daughter.

Oct 9, 2025

Fake IDs and Felony Charges

A 31-year-old man faces felony charges for possessing forged documents following a traffic stop in Sag Harbor early Friday morning.

Oct 9, 2025

Sun’s Glare Was to Blame

A cyclist was transported to Stony Brook Southampton Hospital on Friday afternoon after colliding with a BMW sedan on Route 114 in East Hampton.

Oct 9, 2025

On the Police Logs 10.02.25

Four men were seen “rearranging” the metal benches in front of the Yummylicious ice cream and frozen yogurt shop in Sag Harbor last week. They told a police officer they’d moved the benches “because they wanted to hang out.”

Oct 2, 2025

 

Your support for The East Hampton Star helps us deliver the news, arts, and community information you need. Whether you are an online subscriber, get the paper in the mail, delivered to your door in Manhattan, or are just passing through, every reader counts. We value you for being part of The Star family.

Your subscription to The Star does more than get you great arts, news, sports, and outdoors stories. It makes everything we do possible.