Skip to main content

More Units, Not Only for Seniors

Thu, 09/19/2024 - 12:25

Town weighs plan to increase density for all affordable developments

After a recent move to increase density allowances from eight units an acre to 12 for senior-citizen-only affordable housing developments, the East Hampton Town Board this week discussed making the same adjustment on any affordable housing parcel.

Eric Schantz, the town’s director of housing, said that the main concerns from a planning perspective with allowing the extra density were septic flow and traffic increases. However, since the Suffolk County Department of Health Services doesn’t limit density at all when a development provides its own wastewater treatment, he said density restrictions were purely “self-imposed” on sites with their own sewage plants.

“Obviously, we’re not looking to go ‘sky is the limit’ on this,” he told the board.

“How many existing developments already have sewage treatment?” asked Councilwoman Cate Rogers. The Green at Gardiner’s Point on Three Mile Harbor Road in East Hampton and Gansett Meadows in Amagansett, came the reply from Mr. Schantz, who noted that if the board chooses to permit the change, one of the safeguards would be that the property must have sewage treatment. “So, in a way, it provides an incentive to these properties to update their sewage treatment facilities,” he said.

Other safeguards would be that applicants must complete an impact study on the school district from increased enrollment, and a traffic study.

During the analysis of the recent density increase for the senior-only developments, the board considered worst-case scenarios for traffic. For example, it asked, “If each development maxed out their units at 60” — the town doesn’t allow housing units larger — “how bad would traffic get?” Mr. Schantz’s answer was not bad at all. “We found it doesn’t significantly increase generated traffic on site,” he said at one point. At another, he said, “You’re talking about an additional vehicular trip once every five minutes.”

Mr. Schantz painstakingly went through each of the parcels, developed or not, in the town’s affordable housing overlay districts and said that if they were all developed out to 12 units per acre, that hypothetically, the town could add 160 more affordable units. However, the real number would be much lower.

“Basically, it’s less than a third of what the theoretical max would be,” he told the board. Even if the code is changed, the maximum for each site would remain at 60, and there were other limitations, sometimes based on lot constraints, that would prevent each site from achieving the density ceiling. “I don’t think this change will have a big impact,” he concluded. “We won’t get a substantial number, but we could get more, and every little bit helps.”

The board was tasked with deciding not only if it liked the idea, but also if developers should be required to receive a special permit from the town planning board. Town Supervisor Kathee Burke-Gonzalez didn’t want developers to be turned off to building affordable apartments because of an onerous town requirement.

“Even if they’re adding units to an existing development, under town code right now they would have to go in front of the planning board,” said Mr. Schantz. “The process is really the same. The special permit gives the planning board more standards with which to review the request.” He said that in Southampton Town, where the maximum density is already set to 12, applicants need a special permit from the town board. He argued that giving the special permit approval purview to the planning board instead, would streamline the process.

Councilman Ian Calder-Piedmonte said this was a slightly more complicated question than increasing density for the senior-only affordable housing developments, which is why it was separated out from that legislation. “We didn’t want the senior density to get bogged down,” he said. It came down to economics. Because affordable housing features capped rents, building more units might make the projects more viable for developers. Dimensional regulations wouldn’t change, and he did not think they would affect the town’s character. “We aren’t creating the opportunity for massive development,” he said.

“The affordable housing regulations haven’t changed in quite some time, while the need for affordable housing has increased dramatically,” said Councilwoman Rogers. “If we’re going to use the word ‘crisis’ and mean it, then we should support this type of density for affordable housing.” Adding additional buffers and screening because of the increased density would not be necessary, she said, especially if native plants weren’t going to be required. The board agreed. “Why wall something off? And if it’s not native, I don’t want to see more non-native species around. Gansett Green is not hidden, and it’s beautiful,” she said.

The proposal will get an airing and comments from the Planning Department and board. As part of the New York State Environmental Quality Review Act, an environmental assessment will be conducted. Once those boxes are checked, the board indicated it would be comfortable moving the proposed legislation to a public hearing.

 

Villages

A Day to Celebrate East Hampton Windmills

Time was a breeze on land likely meant the three windmills in East Hampton Village were churning grain. They’re still there, reminders of a time when we were more positively connected to the environment. All three will be open to the public on Saturday, for what Hugh King, the village historian, is calling Windmill Day, from 10 a.m. to 4 p.m.

Oct 10, 2024

Real Estate: Who's Your Neighbor?

The national trend of shell companies owning real estate is not a new phenomenon, but it's one that is solidly in play here on the South Fork — presenting benefits for the actual owners and problems of perception in some communities.

Oct 10, 2024

Services Here for Yom Kippur

Yom Kippur, the Day of Atonement, the holiest day oft he Jewish calendar, begins at sundown tomorrow, and there will be services in East Hampton at the Jewish Center of the Hamptons and Chabad of the Hamptons and in Sag Harbor at Temple Adas Israel and Bay Street Theater, which Gesher | the Bridge Shul will make its temporary home.

Oct 10, 2024

 

Your support for The East Hampton Star helps us deliver the news, arts, and community information you need. Whether you are an online subscriber, get the paper in the mail, delivered to your door in Manhattan, or are just passing through, every reader counts. We value you for being part of The Star family.

Your subscription to The Star does more than get you great arts, news, sports, and outdoors stories. It makes everything we do possible.