The East Hampton Historical Society's 38th annual House and Garden Tour will open the doors of five noteworthy homes for self-guided tours on Nov. 28 from 1 to 4:30 p.m. A benefit cocktail party will be held the night before, on Friday, Nov. 27, from 6 to 8 at the East Hampton residence of Mary Jane and Charles Brock, whose house, originally built in 1799 for Jeremiah Miller, was moved back from the street and expanded in the 1880s.
"The House and Garden Tour offers guests a one-of-a-kind opportunity to go behind the doors of some of East Hampton's most distinctive homes," said Dale Ellen Leff, a trustee of the society who chairs its special events committee. "More than a beloved decades-long tradition, the tour helps support the historical society's museums, exhibitions, and educational programs, ensuring that our community's stories and historic places endure for generations to come."
Lysbeth Marigold, a former trustee and board secretary, said, "Every year the historical society looks to get a 'wow' house, such as Grey Gardens or the Dina Merrill/Ted Hartley house. What it boils down to for me is that people like a house with a story. This year I think we have five 'wow' houses, each with a different story."
And if anyone knows those stories it's Marigold, who elaborated during a telephone conversation.
One example is Onna House, the East Hampton home of the designer, collector, and curator Lisa Perry. Robert Scull, who'd inherited a flourishing taxi business from his father-in-law, bought the house in 1961, and began to collect modern and contemporary art after enlarging his cab company to a fleet of 130. In 1966 The New Yorker called Scull "the busiest, the most powerful, and very probably the most ambitious [art] collector around."
"Scull was the first person to commission Andy Warhol to do a portrait, which started Warhol on an extremely profitable line of portraits for the rest of his life," said Marigold. The subject was his wife, Ethel, a collector of pop and minimalist art in her own right; the portrait, "Ethel Scull 36 Times," is now jointly owned by the Metropolitan Museum and the Whitney Museum.
Scull engaged the architect Paul Lester Wiener, who'd worked with Le Corbusier, to design their midcentury modern weekend residence. "Instead of knocking down trees, as a lot of builders do today, they left this beech tree that has grown up and now covers the entire house, from a Japanese garden in the entranceway," Marigold said. "It's really quite sensational."
Ethel Scull, a famous hostess, was involved in the feminist movement and threw large parties for, among others, the National Organization for Women, which brought such icons as Gloria Steinem and Betty Friedan to the house.
"In a way, Lisa Perry has picked up that gauntlet," Marigold said. "Her first year, she was focused on Japanese women artists, but within a year she pivoted and now shows local women artists and goes to local exhibitions."
Not far away, on Jericho Lane, is a house built in the mid-1850s by a captain of a whaling ship. It stood originally on Division Street in Sag Harbor, but in 1960 that entire section of the street was torn down to make way for Stella Maris Regional School, now the Sag Harbor Learning Center. "Instead of tearing this one down, which is a beautiful three-story federal building, they cut it into three pieces and moved it all the way down 114 onto Jericho Lane," Marigold said.
"I've never seen a more perfectly done house in all my years," she said, "and I've been in the great houses of England." Among its special features are "the glossiest glossy ceilings that I've ever seen. It throws a very complementary, pearlescent light on everybody in the room."
Other notable features include hand-embroidered silk wallpaper and, in all the public rooms, small, medium, and large sailing ships, all hand-carved out of horns. "You can see them once in a while in an antique store, but they must have cornered the market. I've never seen so many in one place."
Another stop on the tour is the house in Amagansett lived in by Arthur Miller and Marilyn Monroe during the summers of 1957 and 1958, where Monroe prepared for her role in "Some Like It Hot" and Miller worked on his screenplay for "The Misfits." Just another actor and writer on the East End.
"I read a quote of hers saying they were the happiest two years of her life," said Marigold. "They really lived here. They went to the beach, and she had a Thunderbird convertible they drove over all the back roads, even to the Springs General Store."
A three-image triptych of Monroe talking on the telephone, taken by the photographer Sam Shaw, now hangs over the very spot where she was photographed. The present owners have kept what had been the primary bedroom and turned it into a guest room. "It has the bed they were in," Marigold said. "Like George Washington! The past and the present all intermingle, and it's all nicely done."
Marigold digressed to recall that when she was growing up in Connecticut, her father played poker with Miller. "I remember when my brother and I were small children, we were sitting on the steps when Arthur Miller and Marilyn Monroe came in. I can add meeting them to my own history."
The other two houses on the tour are a converted potato barn in Wainscott and a house overlooking Gardiner's Bay, whose owners were living on Further Lane when they decided they wanted to be on the water but not on the ocean. They recreated the Further Lane house on the bay, where "Everything flows beautifully, and all the windows overlook the bay."
In addition to the featured homes, guests have been invited to visit Mulford Farm at 10 James Lane to explore the newly restored Mulford Farmhouse. Just down the street, the Hedges Inn will be open for tour participants to check out its rooms and warm up at a hot chocolate bar.
Tickets to the cocktail party, which include entry to the house tour the next day, are $375. Tickets purchased in advance for the tour only are $125 and available on the historical society's website.