Skip to main content

On the Police Logs 12.12.19

Thu, 12/12/2019 - 11:55

East Hampton

A man walking two dogs inside a gated property on Wildflower Road was seen at about 4:30 p.m. on Dec. 2 looking into windows at the house and turning doorknobs. A police report was filed on Friday.

Police were called to investigate a fraudulent scheme involving a Morrell Street resident and a phony village police officer last Thursday. The resident got a call around 10:30 a.m. from someone claiming to be with the Social Security office in Texas, and was told that his Social Security card had been compromised and there were pending charges against him. To avoid charges, he was instructed to buy five Google Play gift cards in the amount of $200 each and send photos of them to a number provided. He went to Walgreen’s in Bridgehampton, purchased the gift cards, and sent them to the number. A few hours later, he was contacted again and told to take all the money out of his bank account and take it to an address in Amityville; if he did not comply, said the caller, the East Hampton Village police would go to his house and arrest him. He withdrew $7,500 from the bank, and soon received a call from a phone number that is associated with the village police. The caller claimed to be an Officer Andrews and said to bring the money to Amityville. At that point, the man became suspicious. He went to the village police station instead, where he was informed there is no officer by that name and no one had been trying to contact him. Town police were notified. While an officer was taking the information, another call came in from the scammers. This time, a real police officer got on the phone and identified himself. The call was immediately disconnected.

East Hampton Village

When a small bird, possibly a yellowtail warbler, was trapped under a Jeep whose driver stopped on Gingerbread Lane just before noon on Dec. 2, an East Hampton Fire Department chief who was driving down the street came to the rescue. With traffic backing up, he used a small stick to coax the bird out. Since the bird did not appear to be injured, the chief let it fly away. The Jeep driver was thankful for the help.

A Capital One bank employee received a call from someone requesting her Social Security number last Thursday. She did not give any information, but wanted the incident documented.

Montauk

A window in a room at the Sea View on Lincoln Road had several cracks in it when a guest checked out on Dec. 1, according to the management. Wen Ying Gamba said he noticed a dog bed was propped up against the window when he went into the room to do turndown service on Nov. 30, one day after the male guest checked in. He did not wish to pursue charges, but said he planned to charge the credit card on file.

Sag Harbor

On Dec. 2, between 7 and 9 p.m., an iPhone 11 Pro Max was taken from a restaurant on Bay Street. It is worth $1,000.

On Dec. 4, an envelope containing $9,000 in cash was taken from a car parked on Main Street between 7:15 and 11:15 p.m.

Springs

A resident of Isle of Wight Road fell victim last month to a fraudulent scheme on eBay. On Nov. 22, he supposedly was the winning bidder for a 2016 Dodge Ram 2500 pickup truck. He made arrangements with the “owner” for a $30,000 wire transfer through People’s United Bank, and received, via email, a promise of delivery, a copy of the truck’s supposed title, and pictures of a truck. On Nov. 26, he received a fraud notification from eBay. The company recommended he file a police report.

Wainscott

A man claiming to be “Nelson Wallace” rented a white 2019 Land Rover sport utility vehicle from Hertz at East Hampton Airport on Oct. 16 and never returned it. Michael C. Norbeck, the owner/manager, filed a report on Dec. 4 after learning that other vehicles, rented using the same fraudulent credit card, had been stolen from other Hertz locations, outside town police jurisdiction. He said the man presented a Delaware driver’s license.

Police were called to the Speedway convenience store on Montauk Highway on Nov. 21, a day after a man stole a can of Red Bull. The store’s surveillance footage showed the man shoving the can into a pocket of his cargo pants, walking out to a pickup truck, leaving the can inside, and then going to the gas station’s bathroom. Mustafa Ketencioglu of Port Jefferson, who works there, confronted the thief, who he believes has stolen from the store in the past. He took cellphone photos before the man drove off in a Chevrolet Silverado.

On the Police Logs 04.23.26

A flashlight-carrying man walking near Church Lane in Springs early Saturday morning was taken to the train station after he told police his friends had left him without a ride home to Hampton Bays after a night out drinking.

Apr 23, 2026

Plea Deal Offered in Montauk Art Show Crash

The woman who police said drove through an art show on the downtown green in Montauk in the overnight hours last June was offered three years of probation.

Apr 23, 2026

No Signals and No Stopping

Police charged a Riverhead woman with a felony in the early hours of Sunday morning after they said they found her to be intoxicated with two children in the car in Amagansett.

Apr 23, 2026

On the Police Logs 04.16.26

The manager of a North Main Street business reported a “defaming” Yelp review to police last week. He identified the writer of the review as a former employee.

Apr 16, 2026

 

Your support for The East Hampton Star helps us deliver the news, arts, and community information you need. Whether you are an online subscriber, get the paper in the mail, delivered to your door in Manhattan, or are just passing through, every reader counts. We value you for being part of The Star family.

Your subscription to The Star does more than get you great arts, news, sports, and outdoors stories. It makes everything we do possible.